1
00:00:12,480 --> 00:00:15,100
A GRIN WITHOUT A CAT

2
00:00:15,380 --> 00:00:19,400
I'm not among those who saw "Potemkin"
when it first came out; I was too young.

3
00:00:19,500 --> 00:00:23,320
But I remember clearly
the shot of the meat,

4
00:00:23,330 --> 00:00:24,300
with the maggots.

5
00:00:26,780 --> 00:00:32,040
And the small tent where the dead lay...

6
00:00:32,220 --> 00:00:35,136
and in front of which the first man stops...

7
00:00:36,220 --> 00:00:39,740
And when the other sailors
take aim at the battleship's bridge.

8
00:00:41,180 --> 00:00:43,620
And, when the officer gives
the order to fire,

9
00:00:44,340 --> 00:00:46,980
A tall sailor with a big
moustache shouts out a word...

10
00:00:47,020 --> 00:00:49,660
that covers the entire screen in big letters:

11
00:00:50,180 --> 00:00:51,300
BROTHERS!

12
00:00:58,160 --> 00:01:04,800
First Part
THE FRAGILE HANDS

13
00:04:09,820 --> 00:04:13,980
Irina, do you come often to these
stairs with tourists?

14
00:04:14,940 --> 00:04:19,539
Yes, very often. Sometimes,
two or three times on the same day,

15
00:04:19,540 --> 00:04:25,180
because I worked for a year
as a translator for tourists in Odessa.

16
00:04:33,360 --> 00:04:35,480
(Jorge Semprún)
In the sixties, everything changed.

17
00:04:35,540 --> 00:04:37,180
We were coming out of the Cold War...

18
00:04:37,500 --> 00:04:39,620
and the Revolution of 1917
belonged in the museums.

19
00:04:40,000 --> 00:04:43,800
The most brilliant minds held that, at last, we'd reached the Age of Reason.

20
00:04:44,080 --> 00:04:46,479
And the only problem left
was to find out when and how...

21
00:04:46,480 --> 00:04:48,840
humanity would reach
a universal standard of civilization.

22
00:04:50,720 --> 00:04:51,840
And then everything came down...

23
00:04:52,040 --> 00:04:53,920
in Cuba, China...

24
00:04:54,360 --> 00:04:58,560
But, if we had to put it in one word
that would evidently be Vietnam.

25
00:05:03,461 --> 00:05:07,561
FROM VIETNAM TO
THE DEATH OF THE CHE

26
00:05:08,720 --> 00:05:10,080
(An American pilot speaks to the camera)

27
00:08:48,080 --> 00:08:52,600
(Paul Vergés)
The war in Vietnam in the '60s and '70s...

28
00:08:54,200 --> 00:08:55,719
was the Spanish Civil War
of today,

29
00:08:55,720 --> 00:08:57,760
is the Spanish Civil War of today.

30
00:08:58,440 --> 00:09:01,600
But the Spanish Civil War at
that time,

31
00:09:02,440 --> 00:09:06,160
a war in whose context was...

32
00:09:06,200 --> 00:09:09,999
the treason of Western Democracies,

33
00:09:10,000 --> 00:09:11,720
was a lost cause.

34
00:09:12,000 --> 00:09:15,800
It was a cause that allowed for
mobilization, crystallization,

35
00:09:15,810 --> 00:09:17,079
and observation.

36
00:09:17,080 --> 00:09:19,720
But, objectively, a lost cause.

37
00:09:20,040 --> 00:09:24,400
On the other hand, the war in Vietnam is
the Spanish Civil War of our days...

38
00:09:24,920 --> 00:09:27,400
but with the possibility of
defeating imperialism...

39
00:09:28,520 --> 00:09:30,800
in a specific spot of the globe.

40
00:10:07,140 --> 00:10:11,820
It wasn't a real mutiny, but a simulated one.

41
00:10:12,820 --> 00:10:15,860
It was, like everything else in
these camps, a spectacle.

42
00:10:18,180 --> 00:10:21,580
A complete repertoire of anti-subversive
techniques. One big game.

43
00:11:31,100 --> 00:11:33,900
There were visitors from all over the world,
specially Latin America.

44
00:11:35,420 --> 00:11:36,860
Who were as in a car showroom,

45
00:11:38,340 --> 00:11:40,620
to see the new models,
the latest technology,

46
00:11:41,100 --> 00:11:44,020
to study, compare and buy
the latest anti-subversive tools.

47
00:12:21,140 --> 00:12:23,420
(Vietnam, 1968)

48
00:12:23,520 --> 00:12:27,960
A loudspeaker plays out the supposed
last words of a Vietcong who died in battle.

49
00:12:29,320 --> 00:12:33,640
His family calls him, but he says:
"It's too late. I'm dead".

50
00:12:35,040 --> 00:12:38,520
And urges his comrades to abandon
the jungle before they die like him.

51
00:13:51,081 --> 00:13:53,381
(Vietnam, 1966)

52
00:14:25,281 --> 00:14:27,681
(Washington DC, 1965)

53
00:16:05,400 --> 00:16:36,880
(Wall Street Executives)

54
00:16:38,700 --> 00:16:43,380
(Paul Vergès)
Vietnam was, and still is,

55
00:16:43,900 --> 00:16:48,619
the only question that can
mobilise the masses...

56
00:16:48,620 --> 00:16:51,020
in Sweden as in Paris,

57
00:16:52,020 --> 00:16:54,979
in the United States and in Moscow,

58
00:16:54,980 --> 00:16:59,220
in Beijing or New Delhi, or Algiers.

59
00:17:00,060 --> 00:17:05,380
That is to say, never before has History put a nation...

60
00:17:06,140 --> 00:17:09,340
in such a convergence point
of all the world's contradictions.

61
00:17:10,580 --> 00:17:12,900
And it is beginning with the
conflict in Vietnam...

62
00:17:13,500 --> 00:17:15,779
that people in the world
felt concerned,

63
00:17:15,780 --> 00:17:20,300
implicated in this struggle for
independence, socialism,

64
00:17:20,940 --> 00:17:22,339
in this struggle for peace.

65
00:17:22,340 --> 00:17:25,460
Today everyone is concerned
about the Vietnamese.

66
00:17:26,580 --> 00:17:30,179
And what, from our perspective,
is exemplary...

67
00:17:30,180 --> 00:17:34,860
is the modesty of the Vietnamese people,
and their realism.

68
00:17:36,620 --> 00:17:39,540
It's a people that,
under the direction of their Party,

69
00:17:40,700 --> 00:17:44,460
makes no reproaches,
shows no bitterness.

70
00:17:45,540 --> 00:17:46,940
But who don't make up any illusions, either.

71
00:17:48,820 --> 00:17:51,180
A people that believes in its own strength.

72
00:17:52,120 --> 00:17:55,240
And, as far as the Vietnamese people
are concerned,

73
00:17:55,880 --> 00:18:01,640
there's no doubt that, for an intelligent
and realist spirit,

74
00:18:03,400 --> 00:18:06,960
taking the decision of liberating Vietnam...

75
00:18:07,960 --> 00:18:09,960
facing the American involvement...

76
00:18:10,600 --> 00:18:12,320
was, obviously, madness.

77
00:18:16,160 --> 00:18:17,400
(Simone Signoret)
We couldn't believe it.

78
00:18:18,160 --> 00:18:19,640
The slogan then was: "Peace in Vietnam".

79
00:18:19,641 --> 00:18:21,641
Just like "Stop the massacres".

80
00:18:22,400 --> 00:18:24,599
A tiny nation, threatened by a giant.

81
00:18:24,600 --> 00:18:27,360
A nation we had to rescue.

82
00:18:28,040 --> 00:18:30,239
(Paris, 1967)
The idea they could win came much later.

83
00:18:30,240 --> 00:18:33,439
After all, don't forget that
"Victory for the Vietcong"...

84
00:18:33,440 --> 00:18:35,040
was a left-wing slogan then.

85
00:18:35,640 --> 00:18:38,240
We never thought that Vietnam could be for the USA...

86
00:18:38,241 --> 00:18:40,241
what Indochina had been for France.

87
00:18:42,000 --> 00:18:47,800
(Paul Cèbe)
I was 18 when I went to Indochina,
and 20 when I came back to France.

88
00:18:49,680 --> 00:18:52,519
In Indochina I learned a lot
from my militant comrades.

89
00:18:52,520 --> 00:18:56,680
In Indochina I met many
"Republican fighters".

90
00:18:57,680 --> 00:19:00,880
They were communist officers,
they are all dead now.

91
00:19:03,360 --> 00:19:04,640
I was sent to Indochina...

92
00:19:09,280 --> 00:19:11,760
to fight the "Yellow danger",
naturally.

93
00:19:12,800 --> 00:19:16,079
Later, I learned it wasn't fair to
fight the "Yellow danger"...

94
00:19:16,080 --> 00:19:19,520
and then I met these
republican officers.

95
00:19:24,280 --> 00:19:27,760
I collaborated with them and
then I discovered books!

96
00:19:29,000 --> 00:19:31,799
I discovered people called Jaurès,

97
00:19:31,800 --> 00:19:35,560
called Lenin, etc.

98
00:19:36,880 --> 00:19:38,200
Well, I came back.

99
00:19:38,920 --> 00:19:43,480
And I realised that the people
who worked in factories,

100
00:19:46,080 --> 00:19:48,480
though they couldn't explain it clearly,

101
00:19:49,800 --> 00:19:53,080
were much like the militants
I'd met in Indochina.

102
00:19:56,920 --> 00:19:59,640
And I realised that these problems
that had to be solved,

103
00:20:04,040 --> 00:20:06,559
the problems that had caught my eye,

104
00:20:06,560 --> 00:20:09,280
that they could only be solved by these people.

105
00:20:12,280 --> 00:20:13,680
The workers.

106
00:20:17,840 --> 00:20:24,140
(Saint- Nazaire, May 1st 1967.
End of the longest strike of the post-war in Sud-Aviation)

107
00:20:25,240 --> 00:20:28,759
I'm sure you will celebrate our victory...

108
00:20:28,760 --> 00:20:32,559
going home with a common purpose,
as when you left it.

109
00:20:32,560 --> 00:20:37,159
You must be united for
the everyday struggle of tomorrow...

110
00:20:37,160 --> 00:20:41,520
and for future confrontations,
for the fight will be long and hard.

111
00:20:42,120 --> 00:20:46,079
Strengthen your unions and work for their unity,

112
00:20:46,080 --> 00:20:50,400
for there cannot be a strong working class...

113
00:20:51,120 --> 00:20:52,680
without powerful unions.

114
00:20:53,040 --> 00:20:56,880
The power of the unions must surpass...

115
00:20:57,040 --> 00:21:00,600
the combined power of the bosses
and the government.

116
00:21:08,180 --> 00:21:10,580
But how did you live through
these two months?

117
00:21:10,620 --> 00:21:17,130
(Georges Frischmann, CGT)
We lived through...
The fishermen helped us, so we had fish.

118
00:21:17,140 --> 00:21:21,099
We queued up for the fish, like
in the war, for bread.

119
00:21:21,100 --> 00:21:23,120
Good... I mean, bad memories.

120
00:21:23,360 --> 00:21:28,160
It was a hard time, but we
had this kind of...

121
00:21:29,180 --> 00:21:34,180
A 60 or 62 year old man told me:
"In these last 2 months I felt alive again".

122
00:21:34,980 --> 00:21:38,659
(Lescure, CGT delegate)
People who had never striked for an hour...

123
00:21:38,660 --> 00:21:40,740
did it for two months.

124
00:21:41,380 --> 00:21:47,219
They saw they could live without many things...

125
00:21:47,220 --> 00:21:51,820
they'd considered necessary until then...

126
00:21:53,780 --> 00:21:56,259
that these things were not essential...

127
00:21:56,260 --> 00:22:00,659
that the essential thing was their human dignity.

128
00:22:00,660 --> 00:22:02,259
It won't end here.

129
00:22:02,260 --> 00:22:05,980
We'll hear about it for a long time.

130
00:22:06,020 --> 00:22:08,060
We'll say: Remember '67?

131
00:22:08,860 --> 00:22:12,179
We feel we had a real movement...

132
00:22:12,180 --> 00:22:15,219
Our elders say that '36 was
a different thing.

133
00:22:15,220 --> 00:22:18,140
We'll tell them: "67 wasn't too bad, either".

134
00:22:19,380 --> 00:22:22,880
(Berlin, June 2, 1967)

135
00:22:23,290 --> 00:22:27,980
(Extract of a militant film made by Berlin's Free University students)

136
00:22:28,040 --> 00:22:29,810
Iran's Shah, murderer of the journalist Shirazi,

137
00:22:29,820 --> 00:22:32,059
and the ministers Faterni and Lofti,

138
00:22:32,060 --> 00:22:34,939
of 71 opposition officers,

139
00:22:34,940 --> 00:22:38,619
of hundreds of communists,
civilians and students...

140
00:22:38,620 --> 00:22:40,260
I was at the June 2nd events.

141
00:22:41,100 --> 00:22:46,300
The Shah was in Berlin. The students
demonstrated against him.

142
00:22:47,100 --> 00:22:48,619
And a student was killed.

143
00:22:48,620 --> 00:22:51,900
This man who earns 400 million dollars...

144
00:22:51,920 --> 00:22:53,899
while his subjects starve to death...

145
00:22:53,900 --> 00:22:56,299
is welcomed by West Germany.

146
00:22:56,300 --> 00:22:58,580
We moved towards the Shah
and he moved towards us.

147
00:23:00,980 --> 00:23:05,300
An unit of Iranian secret police
faces the demonstrators.

148
00:23:06,540 --> 00:23:08,219
The most scary thing was...

149
00:23:08,220 --> 00:23:13,499
(Doctor Scherberwen, father of the student)
when some 12 students...

150
00:23:13,500 --> 00:23:19,299
armed with chains and bats
came towards us...

151
00:23:19,300 --> 00:23:23,059
swinging at everything.

152
00:23:23,060 --> 00:23:25,259
Someone raised a bat over me...

153
00:23:25,260 --> 00:23:30,540
and everyone thought: "They are going
to smash the old man's head".

154
00:23:31,140 --> 00:23:35,340
Someone pulled me and I fell.

155
00:23:56,340 --> 00:24:00,780
We faced the edge of the organised violence
of the system...

156
00:24:01,100 --> 00:24:05,020
This reveals the inherent
weakness of our actions.

157
00:24:05,021 --> 00:24:06,321
(Rudi Dutschke)

158
00:24:07,500 --> 00:24:11,099
They aren't organised.
No one controls them.

159
00:24:11,100 --> 00:24:14,620
They are spontaneously made
by the demonstrators.

160
00:24:14,980 --> 00:24:18,299
The fact that they aren't organised...

161
00:24:18,300 --> 00:24:20,099
is good, but it's also very dangerous.

162
00:24:20,100 --> 00:24:24,300
The organised counter-violence
can crush us, like it did on June 2.

163
00:24:25,400 --> 00:24:28,379
(Daniel Cohn-Bendit)
Germany was a stimulus. Why?

164
00:24:28,380 --> 00:24:32,259
Because German students showed
us it was possible...

165
00:24:32,260 --> 00:24:37,379
to make not only corporative demands
from the university...

166
00:24:37,380 --> 00:24:42,259
but also to ask radical
questions about society...

167
00:24:42,260 --> 00:24:45,659
which could lead to radical
transformations of society.

168
00:24:45,660 --> 00:24:48,260
In this way Germany was indeed
a stimulus.

169
00:24:48,620 --> 00:24:53,980
But the situation here is very
different.

170
00:24:54,220 --> 00:25:00,220
I think it is important to underline the specific
aspects of the situation in France.

171
00:25:00,580 --> 00:25:02,540
In France there is a Communist Party.

172
00:25:02,980 --> 00:25:06,620
In France there is an opposition
which doesn't exist in Germany.

173
00:25:08,060 --> 00:25:12,859
On April 11, 1968, Rudi was gravely wounded by gunfire...

174
00:25:12,860 --> 00:25:14,740
while he cycled in a Berlin street.

175
00:25:15,140 --> 00:25:17,979
He'd written: "We must revolutionise revolutionaries".

176
00:25:17,980 --> 00:25:20,780
A key phrase of the '60s.

177
00:25:22,820 --> 00:25:25,900
(La Paz, Bolivia, June 1967)

178
00:25:43,560 --> 00:25:47,179
I saw in the walls of La Paz
slogans like "¡Viva Fidel!",

179
00:25:47,180 --> 00:25:48,539
hammers and sickles,

180
00:25:48,540 --> 00:25:51,539
as well as posters which asked for the capital...

181
00:25:51,540 --> 00:25:54,620
punishment for Régis Debray,
a guerrilla theoretician,

182
00:25:55,140 --> 00:25:58,320
we knew he was French,
that he was a philosopher...

183
00:25:58,620 --> 00:26:03,440
and that he'd published a book in Maspero titled: "Revolution in the revolution?".

184
00:26:04,382 --> 00:26:05,963
I don't think my book will have much echo.

185
00:26:06,427 --> 00:26:08,164
It would be great if they published it.

186
00:26:08,828 --> 00:26:11,260
And if I didn't publish books I wouldn't be an editor;...

187
00:26:11,295 --> 00:26:14,208
I would be at the Marxist Studies
Institute to define all the concepts,

188
00:26:14,617 --> 00:26:17,729
in a scientific and theoretical way, that,
once the concepts were defined,

189
00:26:18,091 --> 00:26:21,000
we'd use them in books of such perfection...

190
00:26:21,035 --> 00:26:22,960
that all we'd need was for them
to be published to have the Revolution done.

191
00:26:28,581 --> 00:26:30,600
(Black Panthers rally, San Francisco)

192
00:27:18,700 --> 00:27:20,459
There was a profound impression, first of all,

193
00:27:20,460 --> 00:27:24,020
that finally this generation was living its 1917,

194
00:27:24,700 --> 00:27:27,300
that it was finally into
something important.

195
00:27:28,220 --> 00:27:30,380
And this something was the Cultural Revolution,

196
00:27:30,820 --> 00:27:32,810
which aimed to flood the institutions...

197
00:27:32,820 --> 00:27:35,219
and even the Party with a wave...

198
00:27:35,220 --> 00:27:37,819
that would have been seen
as counter-revolutionary...

199
00:27:37,820 --> 00:27:40,420
had it not been personally
approved by Mao.

200
00:27:47,891 --> 00:27:49,300
(Paris, 1962 - Metro Charonne)

201
00:27:49,340 --> 00:27:53,740
And also a new attitude in the
demonstrations, more aggressive,

202
00:27:54,500 --> 00:27:56,460
born from a real need of
striking back,

203
00:27:57,460 --> 00:28:02,820
contrary to what had happened at Charonne,
where there was no response.

204
00:28:04,300 --> 00:28:05,740
Moreover, there was the question of space.

205
00:28:07,180 --> 00:28:08,939
The police lines represented a
kind of order.

206
00:28:08,940 --> 00:28:10,660
The union and student lines another.

207
00:28:13,564 --> 00:28:16,113
And between the two, a space.
A space which had to be filled.

208
00:28:16,260 --> 00:28:18,579
At that moment, anyone in that space...

209
00:28:18,580 --> 00:28:21,419
could only be considered
an alien provocateur.

210
00:28:21,420 --> 00:28:23,700
And maybe they were, after all.

211
00:28:24,500 --> 00:28:26,700
But it made for a new kind of confrontation.

212
00:28:27,500 --> 00:28:29,100
Amidst ourselves, to start with.

213
00:28:30,500 --> 00:28:34,379
When, in October 1967, a protest
was broken up by the fights between...

214
00:28:34,380 --> 00:28:38,059
the pro-communists and the pro-Chinese,
as they were called then,

215
00:28:38,060 --> 00:28:41,460
it wasn't normal. It was something new.

216
00:28:42,300 --> 00:28:45,819
It had a new meaning. And the shouts
for "Unity, unity!"...

217
00:28:45,820 --> 00:28:48,140
from the crowd, meant something too.

218
00:29:04,077 --> 00:29:08,053
And this is where this "New Left" was born.

219
00:29:10,439 --> 00:29:17,568
Maybe what didn't get much attention then
was the rising of the "New Right".

220
00:29:21,100 --> 00:29:24,145
In 1967 Giscard D'Estaing asked me if I'd accept...

221
00:29:24,660 --> 00:29:26,691
taking part of political action with him.

222
00:29:27,589 --> 00:29:29,673
And, more particularly, of organising...

223
00:29:30,294 --> 00:29:32,224
the new United and Independent Republicans Party.

224
00:29:34,860 --> 00:29:38,339
At that time we used to think their
strategies were quite poor.

225
00:29:38,340 --> 00:29:42,651
Today, looking back, we see that indeed they were.

226
00:29:42,860 --> 00:29:45,219
I hope that being off key in music...

227
00:29:45,220 --> 00:29:48,140
will allow me not be so in politics.

228
00:29:53,620 --> 00:29:55,540
On March 13, 1967,

229
00:29:55,760 --> 00:30:00,020
While the workers at Rhodia invented
a new way of striking by occupying.

230
00:30:01,060 --> 00:30:04,900
Fidel Castro announces his rupture with
the Latin American orthodox Communist Parties.

231
00:30:05,801 --> 00:30:07,201
Revolution in the revolution.

232
00:30:08,727 --> 00:30:10,558
There are those...

233
00:30:10,830 --> 00:30:13,025
who call themselves revolutionaries...

234
00:30:13,399 --> 00:30:17,335
and, yet, are against the revolutionary movement.

235
00:30:17,670 --> 00:30:19,968
They demoralise the peoples.

236
00:30:20,239 --> 00:30:24,801
They exploit any setbacks...

237
00:30:25,077 --> 00:30:27,511
to discredit the revolutionary struggle...

238
00:30:27,813 --> 00:30:29,576
against imperialism.

239
00:30:29,915 --> 00:30:32,645
Instead of instilling in people...

240
00:30:32,918 --> 00:30:35,045
a sense of struggle, of the duty,

241
00:30:35,321 --> 00:30:37,721
of the sacred obligation to fight,

242
00:30:37,990 --> 00:30:41,517
they sow the seeds of discouragement.

243
00:30:41,994 --> 00:30:45,760
They support those who are against the guerrilla.

244
00:30:46,165 --> 00:30:50,499
They support those who desert the guerrilla

245
00:30:50,769 --> 00:30:52,828
We have the example of...

246
00:30:53,105 --> 00:30:56,836
Venezuela, where the rightist,
reactionary direction...

247
00:30:57,109 --> 00:30:59,634
of the Communist Party...

248
00:30:59,912 --> 00:31:01,641
has betrayed the guerrilleros...

249
00:31:01,914 --> 00:31:04,382
abandoning them in the mountains.

250
00:31:04,850 --> 00:31:07,045
It has betrayed the very men...

251
00:31:07,319 --> 00:31:11,619
who hold the flag of the revolutionary
struggle and who are still fighting.

252
00:31:12,324 --> 00:31:16,454
(1963, Falcon Mountain)

253
00:31:17,620 --> 00:31:21,720
This interview was recorded in 1963,
before the general elections.

254
00:31:22,131 --> 00:31:24,964
(Douglas Bravo)
It is usually said...

255
00:31:25,171 --> 00:31:27,765
that there is a struggle...

256
00:31:28,040 --> 00:31:31,271
between the opposition and the government.

257
00:31:31,710 --> 00:31:33,871
We go much further:

258
00:31:34,146 --> 00:31:37,377
We hold that it's not a struggle between
the opposition and the government,

259
00:31:37,650 --> 00:31:43,078
it's a struggle between rich and poor.

260
00:31:43,740 --> 00:31:45,140
Apparently, the rich won.

261
00:31:46,340 --> 00:31:50,420
At the last moment, the left called
for abstention, but was ignored.

262
00:31:51,860 --> 00:31:54,380
The right won with Leoni,
and that was the breaking point.

263
00:31:56,060 --> 00:32:00,580
It led to a refoundation movement by the CP and some elements of the extreme left.

264
00:32:01,860 --> 00:32:05,140
The rest, back to the armed struggle,
backed by Cuba.

265
00:32:06,220 --> 00:32:08,739
Little after, Douglas was expelled from the party.

266
00:32:08,740 --> 00:32:11,540
And both lines insisted in hating themselves mutually.

267
00:32:14,740 --> 00:32:18,420
Here, nothing is like China, except, maybe, the greatest heresy:

268
00:32:19,300 --> 00:32:22,140
The Party is no longer the sole expression of the vanguard.

269
00:32:22,580 --> 00:32:24,460
It can be questioned and overruled.

270
00:32:25,500 --> 00:32:28,100
It's not that the Communist Party is
systematically opposed to the armed struggle,

271
00:32:28,140 --> 00:32:30,579
like the extreme left is anxious to proclaim,

272
00:32:30,580 --> 00:32:33,800
but the question is: who leads,
the Party of the guerrilla?

273
00:32:33,820 --> 00:32:37,020
The Cuban answer, that of Douglas
and of Che's,

274
00:32:37,021 --> 00:32:41,021
that of Revolution in the Revolution, is unequivocal.

275
00:32:42,740 --> 00:32:45,460
Political and military unity
under the guerrilla.

276
00:32:47,060 --> 00:32:49,019
This would become incarnated...

277
00:32:49,020 --> 00:32:52,380
in the theories of 'Foquism'.

278
00:32:53,180 --> 00:32:56,380
This can explain what would
happen years later in Bolivia.

279
00:32:57,780 --> 00:33:00,980
But it was there, in Venezuela,
where this split was born...

280
00:33:01,300 --> 00:33:04,139
in the Latin American
revolutionary movement...

281
00:33:04,140 --> 00:33:07,460
which transformed the guerrilla
in a spearhead without a spear.

282
00:33:11,210 --> 00:33:15,374
Sure, the greatest
flaw in the guerrilla...

283
00:33:15,648 --> 00:33:20,642
has been it's lack of experience
and that is only acquired with time.

284
00:33:20,919 --> 00:33:25,879
Naturally some Latin Americans
who don't lack it...

285
00:33:26,158 --> 00:33:29,855
such is the case of
Commander Ernesto Guevara.

286
00:33:30,929 --> 00:33:33,898
I haven't the smallest doubt that:
any country,

287
00:33:34,166 --> 00:33:38,865
any guerrilla front,

288
00:33:39,271 --> 00:33:43,435
which benefits of the cooperation
of Commander Ernesto Guevara,

289
00:33:43,709 --> 00:33:46,075
will follow strictly...

290
00:33:46,545 --> 00:33:50,481
the principles of guerrilla warfare.

291
00:33:50,749 --> 00:33:53,616
And it will be such a good example
to show how when you apply

292
00:33:53,886 --> 00:33:58,220
the technique, the art of the
guerrilla, properly...

293
00:33:58,490 --> 00:34:00,549
there can be no defeat.

294
00:34:02,494 --> 00:34:04,394
I had an interview with Fidel...

295
00:34:04,400 --> 00:34:07,100
(Mario Monje, general secretary of
the Bolivian Communist Party)
on February, '66.

296
00:34:07,466 --> 00:34:09,434
Che was no longer in Cuba...

297
00:34:09,735 --> 00:34:13,569
but I could imagine where he was...

298
00:34:13,839 --> 00:34:16,808
or at least where he had left from.

299
00:34:18,277 --> 00:34:21,678
Then I learned that he had...

300
00:34:22,448 --> 00:34:24,882
left for Congo after his...

301
00:34:25,150 --> 00:34:27,516
spectacular farewell...

302
00:34:27,786 --> 00:34:29,617
and that letter...

303
00:34:29,888 --> 00:34:31,617
which everyone knows.

304
00:34:32,791 --> 00:34:33,917
Fidel,

305
00:34:34,593 --> 00:34:37,721
on this moment I remember many things:...

306
00:34:38,030 --> 00:34:41,124
our meeting at Maria Antonia's,

307
00:34:41,400 --> 00:34:44,130
your invitation to join with you,

308
00:34:44,536 --> 00:34:47,130
and all the tension of the preparations.

309
00:34:47,973 --> 00:34:50,032
One day, they went around asking...

310
00:34:50,309 --> 00:34:52,209
who should be contacted in case of death...

311
00:34:53,545 --> 00:34:55,843
and the real possibility of it...

312
00:34:56,115 --> 00:34:58,276
was a blow to us all.

313
00:34:58,751 --> 00:35:01,447
Later we'd know that it was true.

314
00:35:01,720 --> 00:35:05,349
That in a Revolution one either wins or dies.

315
00:35:05,624 --> 00:35:07,387
- if it is a true revolution -...

316
00:35:08,293 --> 00:35:11,558
I feel I've carried out the duty...

317
00:35:11,764 --> 00:35:15,222
which tied me to the Cuban Revolution and its land...

318
00:35:15,534 --> 00:35:17,627
and I say farewell to you,

319
00:35:17,836 --> 00:35:21,636
to my comrades, and to your people, which is mine too.

320
00:35:22,408 --> 00:35:26,242
My only grave mistake was...

321
00:35:26,512 --> 00:35:29,481
not to trust you fully...

322
00:35:29,748 --> 00:35:32,740
from the start, at the Sierra Maestra...

323
00:35:33,051 --> 00:35:35,713
and not to have understood rapidly enough...

324
00:35:35,988 --> 00:35:39,048
your qualities of revolutionary and leader.

325
00:35:39,324 --> 00:35:40,951
I've lived through great days.

326
00:35:41,226 --> 00:35:44,389
And felt by your side the pride
of belonging to our people...

327
00:35:44,696 --> 00:35:48,132
in the sad and bright days of the
Missile Crisis.

328
00:35:49,435 --> 00:35:51,995
Other lands in the world...

329
00:35:52,271 --> 00:35:55,570
demand the help of my modest efforts.

330
00:35:56,020 --> 00:35:59,700
(Paul Seban)
What do you see in Che Guevara. An ideological guide?

331
00:36:00,820 --> 00:36:03,459
No. If I had to name an
ideological guide...

332
00:36:03,460 --> 00:36:05,580
that would be Marx.

333
00:36:06,100 --> 00:36:08,180
Isn't Marx a bit obsolete.?

334
00:36:09,100 --> 00:36:11,459
I don't think he's obsolete.

335
00:36:11,460 --> 00:36:14,580
Like Sta... Lenin isn't either.

336
00:36:15,220 --> 00:36:17,659
Today, like in the times of Marx, there are people...

337
00:36:17,660 --> 00:36:22,019
who don't have any education,
who suffer,

338
00:36:22,020 --> 00:36:23,700
who starve, etc.

339
00:36:24,260 --> 00:36:27,780
The systematic exploitation continues,
always the same.

340
00:36:29,300 --> 00:36:32,340
I think that... no.
Marx isn't obsolete.

341
00:36:33,078 --> 00:36:35,638
(Caracas, Venezuela)

342
00:36:41,487 --> 00:36:44,012
And it has to be said, that a factor...

343
00:36:44,189 --> 00:36:46,054
has contributed...

344
00:36:46,325 --> 00:36:48,088
to this lack...

345
00:36:48,627 --> 00:36:50,561
of political culture:

346
00:36:51,897 --> 00:36:54,832
And it has been, not the use,

347
00:36:55,133 --> 00:36:56,760
but the abuse of the manuals...

348
00:36:57,035 --> 00:36:59,936
of Marxism-Leninism.

349
00:37:05,677 --> 00:37:09,272
It has to be said that there
is much of clichés,

350
00:37:09,715 --> 00:37:13,310
of stereotyped slogans,

351
00:37:13,585 --> 00:37:16,611
and even, though it's not our
intent to go into...

352
00:37:16,889 --> 00:37:19,050
the analysis of manuals,

353
00:37:19,324 --> 00:37:22,851
some blatant lies!

354
00:37:23,762 --> 00:37:27,323
It is often considered that
the revolutionaries...

355
00:37:27,599 --> 00:37:31,501
are only the members of a Party...

356
00:37:31,770 --> 00:37:34,170
or of a sect,

357
00:37:34,973 --> 00:37:37,407
and we believe there are many revolutionaries...

358
00:37:37,676 --> 00:37:39,667
among the youth...

359
00:37:40,212 --> 00:37:44,376
and among the people without a Party...

360
00:37:45,884 --> 00:37:50,912
New people, who disagree with the
lukewarm,

361
00:37:52,357 --> 00:37:55,292
weak, pseudo-revolutionary positions...

362
00:37:55,561 --> 00:37:57,461
held by some...

363
00:37:57,729 --> 00:38:00,323
who call themselves revolutionaries.

364
00:38:01,066 --> 00:38:03,296
Because when once or twice...

365
00:38:03,569 --> 00:38:06,629
they mentioned...

366
00:38:06,905 --> 00:38:11,938
the famous intercontinental missiles,

367
00:38:13,011 --> 00:38:18,039
everyone here started talking about them...

368
00:38:18,317 --> 00:38:20,285
and counted on them.

369
00:38:20,552 --> 00:38:24,318
As though they had them in their pockets.

370
00:38:28,026 --> 00:38:30,790
That creates, so we see,

371
00:38:31,096 --> 00:38:34,588
an accommodated mentality...

372
00:38:34,866 --> 00:38:36,959
the idea that "we are protected,

373
00:38:37,235 --> 00:38:39,533
let's cross our arms".

374
00:38:40,372 --> 00:38:44,832
When, really, the only correct,
intelligent,

375
00:38:45,110 --> 00:38:48,477
truly revolutionary thing to do...

376
00:38:48,747 --> 00:38:51,511
is to think only in ourselves.

377
00:38:51,817 --> 00:38:55,844
Count on our own strength,

378
00:38:56,121 --> 00:39:00,888
and never relax in our efforts,

379
00:39:01,159 --> 00:39:04,754
so that should the day come we need...

380
00:39:05,497 --> 00:39:07,965
to face direct aggression...

381
00:39:08,233 --> 00:39:10,326
from our imperialist enemies,

382
00:39:10,602 --> 00:39:13,469
we can think first of ourselves...

383
00:39:13,772 --> 00:39:16,332
and only of ourselves,

384
00:39:16,608 --> 00:39:20,806
and be ever-ready to sell
dear our lives...

385
00:39:21,079 --> 00:39:24,913
without counting on anyone to defend us.

386
00:39:27,740 --> 00:39:29,099
There's a terrible reality.

387
00:39:29,100 --> 00:39:32,499
Vietnam incarnates the hopes of victory...

388
00:39:32,500 --> 00:39:35,899
of an entire world, forgotten
and, tragically, alone.

389
00:39:35,900 --> 00:39:37,619
(Message of Che Guevara to the Tricontinental,
May, 1967)

390
00:39:37,620 --> 00:39:40,820
Solidarity with the people of Vietnam...

391
00:39:41,660 --> 00:39:46,180
is like the public's support to the gladiators in Rome.

392
00:39:47,060 --> 00:39:51,140
It's not that you wish well the victim of aggression, but that you share her faith,

393
00:39:51,740 --> 00:39:53,820
you are with her in death or victory.

394
00:39:55,020 --> 00:39:56,980
If we analyse the loneliness of Vietnam...

395
00:39:57,580 --> 00:40:00,420
we will feel the anguish of
this illogical moment for humanity.

396
00:40:01,660 --> 00:40:03,700
American imperialism is responsible for the aggression.

397
00:40:04,580 --> 00:40:07,900
Its immense crimes cover the globe,
as we know only too well.

398
00:40:09,060 --> 00:40:11,819
But there are others who are guilty.
Those that, when they had to make a choice,

399
00:40:11,820 --> 00:40:15,220
faltered in making Vietnam an inviolable socialist territory.

400
00:40:16,180 --> 00:40:18,939
They would have risked a world war...

401
00:40:18,940 --> 00:40:22,020
but that would have forced the
American imperialists into taking a decision.

402
00:40:23,100 --> 00:40:26,300
Those who wage a war of insults and deceit are also guilty,

403
00:40:26,400 --> 00:40:31,140
a war began by representatives of the two great socialist powers.

404
00:40:31,160 --> 00:40:33,139
Then, the famous words:...

405
00:40:33,140 --> 00:40:35,860
"Create 2, 3, many Vietnams".

406
00:40:37,060 --> 00:40:39,540
Terrifying, as only logic can be.

407
00:40:40,340 --> 00:40:42,540
No time for dilettante behaviour or pacifism.

408
00:40:43,220 --> 00:40:47,580
It makes it easy to understand why, after the fiery speeches that followed his death,

409
00:40:48,540 --> 00:40:50,620
there was a palpable sensation of relief.

410
00:40:59,940 --> 00:41:02,380
(Wallander, The Pentagon)

411
00:41:20,261 --> 00:41:22,961
(Major Shelton)

412
00:41:46,841 --> 00:41:49,641
Ladies and gentlemen, good evening.

413
00:41:49,642 --> 00:41:54,142
The man of whom we will speak tonight met a great destiny.

414
00:41:54,843 --> 00:41:56,343
Look well at his face.

415
00:41:57,344 --> 00:42:02,344
Look at this face that has set
itself forever in History...

416
00:42:03,345 --> 00:42:06,345
This face that has been printed in hundreds of millions...

417
00:42:06,346 --> 00:42:09,346
of posters for a large part of our youth.

418
00:42:10,347 --> 00:42:14,347
This face that represents a myth, a symbol...

419
00:42:14,348 --> 00:42:16,348
of the Cuban Revolution.

420
00:42:16,849 --> 00:42:22,349
This man called Ernesto Guevara de la Serna...

421
00:42:22,350 --> 00:42:25,350
known to all as Che Guevara...

422
00:42:25,351 --> 00:42:28,351
or simply as Che.

423
00:42:29,485 --> 00:42:33,078
(Albina du Boisrouvray)
We moved him and then we asked in code...

424
00:42:33,719 --> 00:42:35,528
the military authorities what were we to do.

425
00:42:36,417 --> 00:42:38,418
They told us to keep him alive.

426
00:42:39,513 --> 00:42:42,744
We took him in helicopter to La Higuera, we put him in the school,

427
00:42:43,296 --> 00:42:46,990
where we dressed his wounds, and he spent the night there.

428
00:42:47,719 --> 00:42:50,950
And a Chief of Staff meeting was held...

429
00:42:51,256 --> 00:42:53,349
to decide what was to be done with Che.

430
00:42:53,625 --> 00:42:55,432
The decision was taken in La Paz.

431
00:42:55,433 --> 00:42:58,380
Yes. It happened more or less like
in the movies.

432
00:42:58,740 --> 00:43:02,259
The ambush, Che wounded,
taken to La Higuera,

433
00:43:02,260 --> 00:43:05,260
whose inhabitants received a reward
from the Bolivian government,

434
00:43:06,140 --> 00:43:09,299
the generals' decision to kill him
transmitted to the local authorities...

435
00:43:09,300 --> 00:43:12,620
and executed by a sub-officer
that today lives under a false name.

436
00:43:14,122 --> 00:43:15,611
The order was given at 11 in the morning,

437
00:43:16,125 --> 00:43:18,859
after we'd kept him from 4 in the
afternoon until 11 in the morning.

438
00:43:19,341 --> 00:43:21,285
There's a bizarre detail... What did it say?

439
00:43:21,917 --> 00:43:26,314
That we had to kill him, but to keep the head intact for identification purposes.

440
00:43:50,580 --> 00:43:52,499
They proposed to set me free...

441
00:43:52,500 --> 00:43:55,340
if I signed a public ideological retraction.

442
00:44:36,294 --> 00:44:39,161
Here are the other photos...

443
00:44:39,901 --> 00:44:42,101
(Cuban Television, October 1967)

444
00:44:42,934 --> 00:44:44,561
And another...

445
00:44:47,973 --> 00:44:49,873
They don't appear too well on the screen.

446
00:44:50,075 --> 00:44:51,940
They are newspaper photos.

447
00:44:52,277 --> 00:44:57,213
So they lose a lot of detail...

448
00:45:37,061 --> 00:45:40,061
(Mario Monje)

449
00:45:40,759 --> 00:45:43,853
If you examine all the documents seriously,

450
00:45:44,129 --> 00:45:46,825
you won't find a single...

451
00:45:47,132 --> 00:45:53,827
agreement of the CP or its leaders...

452
00:45:54,105 --> 00:45:57,666
to collaborate with the Che's guerrilla in Bolivia.

453
00:45:58,643 --> 00:45:59,803
There aren't any!

454
00:46:01,012 --> 00:46:03,640
And nevertheless the Che shows up here.

455
00:46:03,915 --> 00:46:08,879
What can explain such a situation?

456
00:46:11,322 --> 00:46:13,449
We'll have to take into account...

457
00:46:13,925 --> 00:46:18,724
what happened in Congo, the time gone by...

458
00:46:18,997 --> 00:46:21,022
since his disappearance.

459
00:46:21,332 --> 00:46:33,436
And take into account a situation of
explaining before the public opinion

460
00:46:34,946 --> 00:46:37,608
He sent his farewell letter for Congo,

461
00:46:37,882 --> 00:46:42,717
And he couldn't think, just like
no revolutionary could think...

462
00:46:42,987 --> 00:46:45,979
that he'd go to Congo, win,

463
00:46:46,291 --> 00:46:48,555
and then go elsewhere, and win again.

464
00:46:48,827 --> 00:46:53,320
No! He was going there, and that
is where he'd probably have to give his life.

465
00:46:53,598 --> 00:46:56,328
But that didn't happen - for many reasons -...

466
00:46:56,601 --> 00:47:00,435
and he had to leave Africa...

467
00:47:00,705 --> 00:47:02,605
and find something else.

468
00:47:02,874 --> 00:47:05,342
He told me himself:...

469
00:47:05,610 --> 00:47:08,170
"I could never go back to Cuba...

470
00:47:08,446 --> 00:47:10,710
For me, that was done for.

471
00:47:11,015 --> 00:47:14,951
I had said farewell very solemnly".

472
00:47:15,253 --> 00:47:18,552
So he had to find somewhere else...

473
00:47:19,791 --> 00:47:21,952
and Bolivia seemed a good place,

474
00:47:22,227 --> 00:47:24,661
among other things,

475
00:47:24,929 --> 00:47:28,296
because we were in a process
of preparation...

476
00:47:28,566 --> 00:47:30,227
and they knew it.

477
00:47:31,236 --> 00:47:33,534
Then he told me:

478
00:47:33,805 --> 00:47:39,641
"I can't give you the revolutionary leadership...

479
00:47:40,044 --> 00:47:43,673
because you don't believe in the guerrilla.

480
00:47:44,115 --> 00:47:46,811
You have other plans,

481
00:47:47,085 --> 00:47:52,655
you believe in a national insurrection

482
00:47:52,924 --> 00:47:55,449
with no set date, no set time...

483
00:47:55,727 --> 00:48:00,221
based on the evolution of the contradictions."

484
00:48:00,532 --> 00:48:02,363
So I told him: Yes,

485
00:48:02,634 --> 00:48:04,534
you've understood me well.

486
00:48:04,969 --> 00:48:07,631
I don't believe the guerrilla...

487
00:48:07,906 --> 00:48:09,737
can lead us to the revolution.

488
00:48:12,076 --> 00:48:15,239
And if you met him today? Would you accept that?

489
00:48:17,949 --> 00:48:23,248
I think he would understand the situation better.

490
00:48:23,521 --> 00:48:28,583
I believe that more than me understanding his tactics,

491
00:48:28,893 --> 00:48:36,364
he'd understand my positions of 1967.

492
00:48:36,668 --> 00:48:40,263
What's more; I think he'd say I was right.

493
00:48:43,700 --> 00:48:48,020
1967 saw the rising of a peculiar kind of teenagers.

494
00:48:48,620 --> 00:48:49,780
They all looked the same.

495
00:48:50,380 --> 00:48:52,260
They recognised each other immediately.

496
00:48:53,900 --> 00:48:57,460
They seemed to have a mute but
absolute knowledge of some things...

497
00:49:00,716 --> 00:49:03,153
while they were completely ignorant of others.

498
00:49:05,860 --> 00:49:08,339
They were incredibly skilful with their hands...

499
00:49:08,340 --> 00:49:10,819
when makings posters, taking out pavement stones,

500
00:49:10,820 --> 00:49:15,100
painting with spray cryptical short
messages that stuck to your mind.

501
00:49:15,780 --> 00:49:18,179
All the time looking for new hands that passed on...

502
00:49:18,180 --> 00:49:21,260
the message they had received,
but didn't managed to decipher entirely.

503
00:49:30,380 --> 00:49:33,500
Those fragile hands left the
mark of their fragility.

504
00:49:34,740 --> 00:49:36,340
They even wrote it in a pamphlet.

505
00:49:37,660 --> 00:49:41,700
"The workers shall take the flag of the
struggle from the fragile hands of the students".

506
00:49:42,480 --> 00:49:43,427
But that was the next year.

507
00:49:44,420 --> 00:49:49,980
I salute the year of 1968
with satisfaction because...

508
00:49:54,781 --> 00:49:57,501
MAY '68
AND ALL THAT:

509
00:50:08,220 --> 00:50:09,720
Why...

510
00:50:13,100 --> 00:50:14,240
do sometimes...

511
00:50:18,300 --> 00:50:19,200
images...

512
00:50:20,300 --> 00:50:21,200
begin...

513
00:50:22,380 --> 00:50:23,760
to shake?

514
00:50:24,240 --> 00:50:27,440
For me, May '68 happened in the Boulevard Saint-Michel.

515
00:50:28,640 --> 00:50:30,720
For me in Prague, in summer '68.

516
00:50:32,600 --> 00:50:35,000
When I saw the Russians I saw the shaking.

517
00:50:35,580 --> 00:50:38,140
I thought I'd managed to control my hands,

518
00:50:38,141 --> 00:50:41,141
but it spread to the camera.

519
00:50:49,200 --> 00:50:50,760
In Santiago de Chile,

520
00:50:50,761 --> 00:50:52,761
the camera slowed itself.

521
00:50:53,920 --> 00:50:57,360
Maybe I was only annoyed to see the situation
reversed, so to say,

522
00:50:58,120 --> 00:51:00,319
and see the charges and the weapons I'd seen used...

523
00:51:00,320 --> 00:51:06,340
so many times against the left in such places as...

524
00:51:06,341 --> 00:51:10,041
Berlin, Lovaine and the United States.

525
00:51:45,680 --> 00:51:48,480
(April 11, 1968)

526
00:51:56,040 --> 00:51:59,840
In some minutes, when I finish work, I'll stand guard...

527
00:52:01,560 --> 00:52:04,880
next to the coffin of a Léon Nicod...

528
00:52:06,120 --> 00:52:07,840
who died age 82.

529
00:52:09,480 --> 00:52:11,360
Died, like every real communist,

530
00:52:12,400 --> 00:52:14,120
in the most complete poverty.

531
00:52:15,600 --> 00:52:19,320
His family was the Party.
His life was the Party.

532
00:52:20,680 --> 00:52:22,840
He founded and carried it with his arms...

533
00:52:23,240 --> 00:52:25,800
for over 20 years.

534
00:52:27,160 --> 00:52:31,200
He was beaten up more than 20 times by the cops,
on horseback or riot gear.

535
00:52:31,920 --> 00:52:34,240
He was questioned a thousand times.

536
00:52:34,600 --> 00:52:36,520
He spent many years of his life in jail.

537
00:52:37,800 --> 00:52:39,039
I knew him little, enough...

538
00:52:39,040 --> 00:52:42,560
to know that his intelligence was
far above average.

539
00:52:43,360 --> 00:52:48,120
He had great humility, tenderness and infinite patience.

540
00:52:49,880 --> 00:52:52,480
He sacrificed it all for the Party,

541
00:52:53,400 --> 00:52:54,879
for the working class,

542
00:52:54,880 --> 00:52:56,600
including his family.

543
00:52:57,360 --> 00:53:00,880
He never had time to work, to travel,

544
00:53:01,760 --> 00:53:04,079
to enjoy these things...

545
00:53:04,080 --> 00:53:06,400
he'd struggled for.

546
00:53:14,941 --> 00:53:16,884
Mayday, 1968, the extreme left...

547
00:53:17,349 --> 00:53:18,926
tries to join the cortège of the 'serious people'...

548
00:53:19,824 --> 00:53:20,385
it doesn't work...

549
00:53:20,468 --> 00:53:22,079
And how is that anticommunism?

550
00:53:22,503 --> 00:53:24,374
Anticommunism is the opposite pole of the left.

551
00:53:24,839 --> 00:53:28,642
These are leftists, amateurs, Trotskists, Anarchists and others,

552
00:53:29,014 --> 00:53:33,031
who take care of spreading anticommunism from inside the working class,

553
00:53:33,404 --> 00:53:38,609
and by doing so, promote division and do a distinguished service to the powerful,

554
00:53:39,070 --> 00:53:41,910
so nobody should accept they march with us.

555
00:53:49,160 --> 00:53:51,719
Courage does not mean
to shout out in the street...

556
00:53:51,720 --> 00:53:56,200
"Ho Chi Minh! Ho Ho!"
or "Guevara! Che Che!"

557
00:53:57,800 --> 00:54:01,759
Courage, for an intelligent person, is not to allow...

558
00:54:01,760 --> 00:54:03,880
himself to become a bloody hassle.

559
00:54:05,120 --> 00:54:07,959
To have that false courage of getting killed tomorrow...

560
00:54:07,960 --> 00:54:11,880
in a 'revolutionary' struggle,
in the name of the 'revolution'.

561
00:54:12,680 --> 00:54:16,200
But never have this authentic courage,
this everyday courage,

562
00:54:17,080 --> 00:54:21,640
which consists of sacrificing your
personality completely to be effective.

563
00:54:23,120 --> 00:54:24,160
There you are.

564
00:54:25,200 --> 00:54:26,280
I'm writing you.

565
00:54:27,080 --> 00:54:30,079
That's not true. I'm writing to
myself as much as to you.

566
00:54:30,080 --> 00:54:33,000
And probably, even more,
to some twenty others.

567
00:54:33,760 --> 00:54:35,280
What is left to say?

568
00:54:36,480 --> 00:54:39,279
That between the castle and the garden...

569
00:54:39,280 --> 00:54:42,520
is the dictatorship of the proletariat?

570
00:54:47,200 --> 00:54:52,200
The working class is neither beautiful, nor good, nor romantic.

571
00:54:52,760 --> 00:54:53,760
It is brutal.

572
00:54:55,880 --> 00:54:57,440
The working class is right.

573
00:54:58,400 --> 00:55:00,120
It does not need to be explained.

574
00:55:02,200 --> 00:55:04,639
(Philippe de Joinet)
And there's also the fact that man...

575
00:55:04,640 --> 00:55:09,520
is a strange and curious animal,

576
00:55:10,640 --> 00:55:13,800
extremely sensible to its surroundings.

577
00:55:14,520 --> 00:55:17,319
It is so because, of all known animals,

578
00:55:17,320 --> 00:55:19,600
it is the one with the strongest sense of emotion...

579
00:55:20,160 --> 00:55:22,720
and the most developed affection.

580
00:55:23,120 --> 00:55:28,280
I believe that what happened was
the crystallization of an emotion...

581
00:55:29,200 --> 00:55:34,360
that developed from and fed on the student movement.

582
00:55:35,040 --> 00:55:36,079
Because we must not forget...

583
00:55:36,080 --> 00:55:40,239
that it all began with solidarity...

584
00:55:40,240 --> 00:55:43,280
with the students...

585
00:55:43,840 --> 00:55:45,799
after the incidents...

586
00:55:45,800 --> 00:55:50,159
provoked by the order given to the police...

587
00:55:50,160 --> 00:55:52,120
of going inside the Sorbonne.

588
00:55:53,920 --> 00:55:58,360
What I mean to say is that, indeed, we have occupied the Sorbonne.

589
00:56:00,600 --> 00:56:02,480
(The Sorbonne, May 3)

590
00:56:16,400 --> 00:56:17,600
It wasn't a real surprise.

591
00:56:18,040 --> 00:56:23,040
We knew the cycle action-repression-mobilization,
new repression, new mobilisation...

592
00:56:23,961 --> 00:56:28,533
We'd seen it in every American campi throughout 1967.

593
00:57:50,840 --> 00:57:54,040
(Paris, Latin Quarter, May 6)

594
00:58:05,540 --> 00:58:07,500
This kind of situation can lead to a double confusion.

595
00:58:08,580 --> 00:58:11,299
At once, the State reveals its oppressive side.

596
00:58:11,300 --> 00:58:15,300
The one that stays more-or-less hidden in everyday life.

597
00:58:17,140 --> 00:58:18,940
But now it has to show its strength.

598
00:58:19,900 --> 00:58:22,339
And, to do so, it allows the police to use...

599
00:58:22,340 --> 00:58:24,900
equipment that nobody even knew existed.

600
00:58:26,900 --> 00:58:30,660
Perfect. For the demonstrator, the State appeared like a vision,

601
00:58:31,340 --> 00:58:32,860
like the Virgin of Lourdes.

602
00:58:33,580 --> 00:58:34,580
It is a revelation.

603
00:58:34,680 --> 00:58:36,839
In extreme cases, someone has the power...

604
00:58:36,840 --> 00:58:40,019
(Italy)
to decide by which side of the road you can walk.

605
00:58:40,054 --> 00:58:43,723
(India)
And, if you choose the wrong side,
they'll kick you out to the right one.

606
00:58:43,840 --> 00:58:48,160
Thus, that thing which forbids you to cross the road is the State.

607
00:58:48,220 --> 00:58:52,280
But if you cross it, and force that something to retreat,

608
00:58:52,440 --> 00:58:54,320
(Ireland)
it is the State that retreats.

609
00:59:14,064 --> 00:59:15,987
Comic Intermezzo

610
00:59:17,061 --> 00:59:21,348
A few days ago, Mr. Minister, you declared
that a handful of agitators...

611
00:59:22,211 --> 00:59:23,670
were responsible for the current disorder.

612
00:59:24,438 --> 00:59:27,172
If you really think that there aren't
more than a handful of these people,

613
00:59:28,782 --> 00:59:34,920
Do you really believe that the demonstrations
of Friday and today would have had so much echo?

614
00:59:36,841 --> 00:59:39,418
(Alain Peyrefitte)
I think we don't have to exaggerate.

615
00:59:40,643 --> 00:59:44,425
The demonstrations of Friday and
of Today are profoundly deplorable,

616
00:59:46,138 --> 00:59:54,143
profoundly condemnable, but they have
not had the violence of the demonstrations...

617
00:59:55,892 --> 00:59:59,830
of Berlin, Warsaw, Bonn, Rome, Algiers, Lovaine...

618
01:00:01,595 --> 01:00:04,303
or Columbia, yesterday, in the United States.

619
01:00:05,245 --> 01:00:08,686
We don't have to exaggerate the
proportion of students of the University of Paris.

620
01:00:09,503 --> 01:00:12,418
There are 160.000 students, and the vast majority of them...

621
01:00:13,030 --> 01:00:18,151
wants to work in peace and the
security forces don't intervene to protect them.

622
01:00:26,320 --> 01:00:27,360
What are you going to do?

623
01:00:28,400 --> 01:00:31,199
My intention is to say 'yes' to constructive dialogue...

624
01:00:31,200 --> 01:00:32,640
and 'no' to violence.

625
01:00:33,520 --> 01:00:35,399
We must put an end to the escalation of violence.

626
01:00:35,400 --> 01:00:38,200
We must do it without heating up passions.

627
01:00:38,600 --> 01:00:43,120
We must recover calm and allow everyone to think.

628
01:00:44,200 --> 01:00:48,400
Today youth is expressing its hatred for a certain kind of society...

629
01:00:48,760 --> 01:00:51,000
(May 10, Rue Gay-Lussac)
going out and building up barricades.

630
01:00:56,269 --> 01:01:02,280
Occupation of the Latin Quarter without provocation to the police.

631
01:01:02,944 --> 01:01:06,507
We won't attack the police.

632
01:01:07,443 --> 01:01:16,622
I ask you, first of all, to the people behind me on the barricade...

633
01:01:17,749 --> 01:01:21,071
A barricade at Rue Drouet that reaches up practically to the second floor.

634
01:01:21,664 --> 01:01:26,256
On that barricade, as in 1848,

635
01:01:26,630 --> 01:01:28,461
flies a flag; a black flag, a red flag...

636
01:01:28,945 --> 01:01:30,906
But now they are telling me that in all this there is an impression...

637
01:01:31,299 --> 01:01:33,554
of a very calm environment, amusing, even.

638
01:01:33,926 --> 01:01:36,677
Well, listen, up to the last minutes there was...

639
01:01:37,006 --> 01:01:39,343
as you said, a calm environment,

640
01:01:39,736 --> 01:01:42,261
but we have received recent information...

641
01:01:42,605 --> 01:01:44,254
which leads us to believe that the police will react,

642
01:01:45,050 --> 01:01:47,354
here, now, there is some unease...

643
01:01:48,130 --> 01:01:52,762
sincerely, I ask the defenders of the barricade that they don't stand on it,

644
01:01:53,384 --> 01:01:56,875
but behind it, because a barricade is raised for protection.

645
01:01:57,542 --> 01:02:02,727
Not on the cars, but behind them. Listen, I've been talking to you for an hour...

646
01:02:05,220 --> 01:02:07,939
There has been an incident at a barricade...

647
01:02:08,655 --> 01:02:11,645
on the end of the Rue Gay-Lussac.

648
01:02:12,077 --> 01:02:15,762
The students have been dispersed with tear-gas

649
01:02:17,392 --> 01:02:21,609
There is a foul-smelling fog...

650
01:02:22,062 --> 01:02:25,104
I can't say whether this is normal tear-gas...

651
01:02:26,160 --> 01:02:28,769
Now they are retreating to their barricades...

652
01:02:29,238 --> 01:02:32,512
and the CRS are going down Boulevard Saint-Michel.

653
01:02:33,093 --> 01:02:35,893
If this society needs all this police force to defend...

654
01:02:36,295 --> 01:02:39,828
the people in power, then our only goal...

655
01:02:40,444 --> 01:02:43,300
is that they assume their responsibilities knowing exactly...

656
01:02:43,645 --> 01:02:46,112
what is happening in the streets, because, whether or not they see it, today...

657
01:02:46,503 --> 01:02:47,930
politics are done in the streets.

658
01:02:48,496 --> 01:02:52,844
Why is it that the police have decided to tear down these barricades,

659
01:02:53,377 --> 01:02:55,741
tear down these ramparts raised by the students?

660
01:02:56,284 --> 01:02:57,968
They must proceed to re-establish circulation,

661
01:02:58,379 --> 01:03:00,061
because, even though now it's 2AM,

662
01:03:00,472 --> 01:03:05,867
in a few hours the cars must be able to run through the quarter,

663
01:03:06,392 --> 01:03:08,780
and perhaps that is why now...

664
01:03:09,209 --> 01:03:11,606
the police have decided to clear the quarter,

665
01:03:11,929 --> 01:03:15,036
specially the Boulevard Saint-Michel, the Rue Saint Jacques and the Rue Gay-Lussac.

666
01:03:20,799 --> 01:03:23,609
Listen, I take up the microphone because I come from the first barricade.

667
01:03:24,514 --> 01:03:27,482
The occupation of the Latin Quarter went fine until 8PM,

668
01:03:28,430 --> 01:03:34,248
it was the police that set off the incidents attacking us with chlorine grenade-launchers.

669
01:03:34,964 --> 01:03:36,834
That is to say, that at this moment, of two things, one:...

670
01:03:37,267 --> 01:03:39,009
The protesters being unable to retreat,

671
01:03:39,651 --> 01:03:42,564
either the police leaves or there will be a massacre worse than Charonne.

672
01:03:45,050 --> 01:03:46,518
Birth of a legend.

673
01:03:47,988 --> 01:03:52,458
They had learned that the workers would assemble at Strasbourg-Saint-Denis.

674
01:03:55,940 --> 01:03:58,659
How much of the paving was taken of the road?

675
01:03:59,111 --> 01:04:01,348
Look, there are places of the road, for example...

676
01:04:02,102 --> 01:04:05,051
the Saint Jacques crossing, where the whole of the road was unpaved,

677
01:04:05,664 --> 01:04:08,583
look, sand, nothing but sand, and the rest...

678
01:04:08,956 --> 01:04:09,983
Birth of an image.

679
01:04:12,720 --> 01:04:16,175
Some CRS have fired their grenades inside the apartments...

680
01:04:16,767 --> 01:04:19,286
No, I don't believe they have shot at the apartments,

681
01:04:19,617 --> 01:04:23,010
they must have aimed at the barricades and some grenades went off target.

682
01:04:23,834 --> 01:04:26,886
No, there's no doubt about, the CRS responded...

683
01:04:27,699 --> 01:04:32,289
firing at the windows, with some grenades reaching the sixth floor.

684
01:04:33,115 --> 01:04:34,927
Well, I receive the information as you give it.

685
01:04:35,500 --> 01:04:37,484
Bernard Lalanne, you are at the Ministry. What's happening there?

686
01:04:38,319 --> 01:04:40,120
Well, nothing at all is happening here.

687
01:04:44,964 --> 01:04:49,531
There were two traffic lights that carried on organising an imaginary traffic...

688
01:04:50,176 --> 01:04:53,470
This is the tactic employed by the police to clear the barricades:...

689
01:04:54,008 --> 01:04:57,908
They set them alight and then fire tear-gas grenades over it,

690
01:04:58,553 --> 01:05:01,691
so the students are forced to abandon barricade after barricade...

691
01:05:02,137 --> 01:05:03,776
We see ourselves forced to use a scarf to be able to...

692
01:05:04,187 --> 01:05:05,879
Attention, no unsuitable heroics, please.

693
01:05:06,422 --> 01:05:08,084
The police are forced to raise their bucklers.

694
01:05:15,392 --> 01:05:16,481
Retreat, retreat!

695
01:05:18,060 --> 01:05:21,394
Indeed, the street fighting is over.

696
01:05:21,845 --> 01:05:25,429
Right now the students are trying to escape through the alleys...

697
01:05:25,893 --> 01:05:28,420
of the Latin Quarter, and there are police cars...

698
01:05:29,556 --> 01:05:31,290
patrolling every street of the Latin Quarter,

699
01:05:31,962 --> 01:05:35,557
and every time they find a group of two, three, or four students,

700
01:05:36,554 --> 01:05:40,115
the police get off and it's always the same scene, a few blows and they arrest them.

701
01:05:43,821 --> 01:05:47,507
On the other hand, I'd like to say the the state of the Rue Gay-Lussac,

702
01:05:47,921 --> 01:05:49,971
the state of the entire Boulevard Saint-Michel, is sad.

703
01:05:50,745 --> 01:05:53,052
When I saw it all at 06:30AM,

704
01:05:53,478 --> 01:05:55,469
at that moment a door woman came out in her robes to look at all this,

705
01:05:56,215 --> 01:05:58,410
and the poor woman started crying.

706
01:05:59,092 --> 01:06:02,587
I understand that woman because, really, there is nothing left,

707
01:06:03,027 --> 01:06:05,888
one has the impression that a storm, a revolution, has taken place here.

708
01:06:13,802 --> 01:06:15,240
Compared to no matter what street in Ireland,

709
01:06:15,956 --> 01:06:17,447
no matter what conflict in South America,

710
01:06:18,130 --> 01:06:19,563
the night of the barricades is derisory.

711
01:06:20,397 --> 01:06:22,449
But Gaullist France had just let herself be persuaded...

712
01:06:23,033 --> 01:06:25,059
that it wasn't immune to what was shaking the rest of the world;...

713
01:06:26,106 --> 01:06:27,783
a well-established idea then.

714
01:06:28,469 --> 01:06:30,243
And when the streets of Paris started looking like...

715
01:06:30,634 --> 01:06:32,870
those of the great cities of Europe and America of the year '68,

716
01:06:33,472 --> 01:06:35,486
it started to think that something had been kept hidden from it.

717
01:06:59,020 --> 01:07:03,420
That time showed us that street violence
does not lead automatically to political change.

718
01:07:04,700 --> 01:07:07,500
The award to the best dramatical confrontation...

719
01:07:07,900 --> 01:07:09,100
was deservedly given to Japan,

720
01:07:09,780 --> 01:07:11,220
where the government didn't even flinch.

721
01:07:12,340 --> 01:07:15,940
Insignificant, by contrast, were the little barricades of Santiago de Chile.

722
01:07:17,980 --> 01:07:20,580
The tag on the reel says, "March, 1968".

723
01:07:22,380 --> 01:07:24,499
A march against inflation led by...

724
01:07:24,500 --> 01:07:28,740
the sister of the socialist candidate
to the presidency, Laura Allende.

725
01:07:32,380 --> 01:07:34,300
Another fragment from March '68

726
01:07:34,440 --> 01:07:36,960
In Brasil, the funeral of
Luis Edson, a student...

727
01:07:37,000 --> 01:07:39,600
murdered by the police during a demonstration.

728
01:07:40,520 --> 01:07:43,079
In Latin America, a whole generation...

729
01:07:43,080 --> 01:07:47,280
of political fighters would end up
under fascist regimes.

730
01:07:48,000 --> 01:07:50,000
Though France had arrived a bit late to join the club,

731
01:07:50,800 --> 01:07:52,320
it had its own veterans.

732
01:07:52,680 --> 01:07:53,840
I was at the barricades.

733
01:07:54,480 --> 01:07:57,719
When I was there I never talked of reformism.

734
01:07:57,720 --> 01:07:59,120
I looked only for one thing.

735
01:07:59,520 --> 01:08:04,920
How to drown De Gaulle and the
entire fucking bourgeoisie.

736
01:08:05,280 --> 01:08:07,360
The MPs have discussed for 10 years.

737
01:08:07,920 --> 01:08:10,240
And in 10 years they got nothing.

738
01:08:10,600 --> 01:08:13,978
We, on the barricades, put the State on its knees.

739
01:08:13,979 --> 01:08:16,713
We want to give power to the workers' councils in the factories...

740
01:08:17,729 --> 01:08:19,236
to the workers' and peasants' councils.

741
01:08:19,779 --> 01:08:22,555
And a soviet-type democracy... Direct democracy

742
01:08:23,219 --> 01:08:25,987
and not universal suffrage which is
the most elaborated form of social dictatorship

743
01:08:27,156 --> 01:08:31,543
(University Director Chapelle)
What astounds me is this dogmatism from one part and this utopia:...

744
01:08:32,451 --> 01:08:34,305
(May 14, "Zoom")
Wanting to supress exams, no less,

745
01:08:35,179 --> 01:08:37,332
exams for which I haven't much affection, by the way,

746
01:08:37,843 --> 01:08:39,845
without presenting an alternative.

747
01:08:40,312 --> 01:08:44,893
And that actually puts your fellow students in great difficulties...

748
01:08:45,111 --> 01:08:45,784
(Alain Geismar)
I'll propose one:

749
01:08:46,225 --> 01:08:47,916
You get an amphitheatre and you fill it with professors and students,

750
01:08:48,104 --> 01:08:49,917
you put a professor and a student at the board...

751
01:08:50,467 --> 01:08:51,986
and the professor poses questions to the student.

752
01:08:51,987 --> 01:08:54,749
If the hall finds the questions to be stupid, the teacher is changed.

753
01:08:55,652 --> 01:09:01,581
If not, it is the hall who judges the student and decides if the answers are good or not.

754
01:09:01,582 --> 01:09:04,462
It is an experiment I'd like to see tried.

755
01:09:04,463 --> 01:09:07,066
(M. Fanton - Secretary Of State for Universities)
For the National Superior Teaching Union,

756
01:09:07,263 --> 01:09:10,108
such proposals are effectively revolutionary,

757
01:09:10,763 --> 01:09:12,764
I have never heard any proposal so revolutionary...

758
01:09:13,002 --> 01:09:18,653
from any teacher, none. And it really surprises me.

759
01:09:19,049 --> 01:09:20,588
Yes, it could happen, but this isn't serious!

760
01:09:20,589 --> 01:09:24,340
So you think these events have been orchestrated from abroad?

761
01:09:24,740 --> 01:09:27,820
Yes, of course I do.

762
01:09:28,420 --> 01:09:29,900
What makes you think so?
The events themselves.

763
01:09:31,020 --> 01:09:32,779
But, what? Could you explain?

764
01:09:32,780 --> 01:09:36,219
It's anarchy. They are foreign anarchists,

765
01:09:36,220 --> 01:09:39,140
French or not, they don't respect anything,
all they do is to commit sacrilege.

766
01:09:40,300 --> 01:09:41,380
What do you think of Cohn-Bendit?

767
01:09:42,300 --> 01:09:43,940
I detest him.
Why?

768
01:09:44,620 --> 01:09:48,140
He shouldn't stir things up here.
He should have stayed in Germany.

769
01:09:48,580 --> 01:09:51,780
Who do you think pays him?
I don't know.

770
01:09:52,740 --> 01:09:56,620
Not the French government. You've been misinformed.

771
01:09:56,820 --> 01:09:58,099
Who do you think does it?

772
01:09:58,100 --> 01:10:00,980
He crossed the border in a
car that belongs to the Chinese Embassy.

773
01:10:07,340 --> 01:10:08,540
They have the right...

774
01:10:09,580 --> 01:10:12,900
to decide where they go.
It's not our style of 'demo'.

775
01:10:14,473 --> 01:10:16,425
Our style of 'demo' is that in which people have the possibility of thinking...

776
01:10:17,307 --> 01:10:20,125
not provoke, provoke, provoke.

777
01:10:22,687 --> 01:10:24,701
(Renault-Cléon)
On May 15 the workers of Cléon go on strike.

778
01:10:25,978 --> 01:10:30,283
Taking their example, workers of Renault,

779
01:10:30,627 --> 01:10:34,184
(Sud-Aviation)
and, little by little, all the country, follow them...

780
01:10:35,239 --> 01:10:36,889
the objectives they set themselves...

781
01:10:39,140 --> 01:10:40,580
The factory is ours and here we are.

782
01:10:42,220 --> 01:10:43,780
Now we are the bosses!

783
01:10:44,140 --> 01:10:47,740
they will negotiate demands
that have been standing for years.

784
01:10:48,486 --> 01:10:49,850
It spreads. It spreads everywhere!

785
01:10:53,860 --> 01:10:57,660
I went to many union meetings myself,

786
01:10:57,700 --> 01:10:59,819
(The Sorbonne)
I've been to many strike committees...

787
01:10:59,820 --> 01:11:05,060
and I've seen how the bosses talk to the workers.

788
01:11:05,300 --> 01:11:07,340
They are terrified.

789
01:11:07,860 --> 01:11:10,060
And when someone is terrified,
he is prone to give in.

790
01:11:10,700 --> 01:11:13,539
And when someone actually gives
in, you have to act.

791
01:11:13,540 --> 01:11:16,420
What are beautiful words and discussions
and all this good for?

792
01:11:16,980 --> 01:11:20,298
It is still certain that the bourgeoisie will never...

793
01:11:20,299 --> 01:11:24,339
simply give us a single iota of its power.

794
01:11:25,139 --> 01:11:29,178
So now you must choose.
Do you want the revolution?

795
01:11:29,179 --> 01:11:33,379
If yes: How do you do it?
Who do you do it with?

796
01:11:33,779 --> 01:11:36,219
What is the enemy's class?
To which class do you belong?

797
01:11:36,939 --> 01:11:39,418
Well, if what you want is a reform...

798
01:11:39,419 --> 01:11:42,499
I must ask myself: What the hell are you doing here with me?

799
01:11:44,379 --> 01:11:47,739
I think the student movement
and the reforms it reclaims...

800
01:11:48,899 --> 01:11:50,419
are very valuable...

801
01:11:51,099 --> 01:11:55,099
but they don't fit in with the demands made at the factories.

802
01:11:55,539 --> 01:11:58,058
We are going through a complicated moment.

803
01:11:58,059 --> 01:12:00,899
(Georges Séguy, CGT leader)
We have realised...

804
01:12:01,819 --> 01:12:05,339
we must take into consideration two essential factors:

805
01:12:06,499 --> 01:12:07,619
Firstly,

806
01:12:07,939 --> 01:12:12,299
the underestimation of the
profundity of the class movement...

807
01:12:12,699 --> 01:12:15,539
that has followed the eruption of the student movement.

808
01:12:16,579 --> 01:12:17,698
Secondly,

809
01:12:17,699 --> 01:12:20,979
the attempts from the left to make it lose its way...

810
01:12:21,579 --> 01:12:24,339
and the attempts of certain elements...

811
01:12:25,139 --> 01:12:27,339
to take the place...

812
01:12:27,379 --> 01:12:32,059
of the workers' organisations,
particularly the CGT's,

813
01:12:32,859 --> 01:12:37,939
trying to overtake the leadership of
the movement in their own benefit.

814
01:12:38,499 --> 01:12:42,899
They started a movement,
brought us into the fight...

815
01:12:43,499 --> 01:12:47,179
not forcibly. To be frank, they awoke us.

816
01:12:48,179 --> 01:12:49,939
(March 1969, Saint Florentin)
I don't understand why, during the strikes...

817
01:12:49,979 --> 01:12:55,819
the unions, who were those who called them...

818
01:12:56,379 --> 01:12:58,659
No, you're wrong!

819
01:12:59,419 --> 01:13:02,299
They were against the strikes.
Not one union called for a strike.

820
01:13:03,419 --> 01:13:05,178
(Extract of a CGT propaganda film, 1969)

821
01:13:05,179 --> 01:13:08,898
(May '68, Sud-Aviation)
The union representatives got together and said:

822
01:13:08,899 --> 01:13:12,619
"We must make a decision today and propose it to the workers immediately".

823
01:13:13,179 --> 01:13:17,179
Then it was when three unions, of their own accord, said:

824
01:13:17,739 --> 01:13:19,939
"We must assemble the workers outside of the offices...

825
01:13:20,179 --> 01:13:23,259
and ask them if they agree to occupy the factory".

826
01:13:23,939 --> 01:13:25,619
They offered their support because...

827
01:13:26,019 --> 01:13:28,059
they knew that, one way or another, it would happen.

828
01:13:28,659 --> 01:13:31,059
It began by itself. They didn't want to push people to strike.

829
01:13:31,579 --> 01:13:33,699
They slowed things down when they went too far.

830
01:13:35,339 --> 01:13:37,098
But the government provoked the strike...

831
01:13:37,099 --> 01:13:38,858
because it was afraid.

832
01:13:38,859 --> 01:13:41,858
Because if a confidence vote was taken...

833
01:13:41,859 --> 01:13:43,778
they knew they'd lose.

834
01:13:43,779 --> 01:13:46,378
And, moreover, it meant retaking with the government...

835
01:13:46,379 --> 01:13:47,938
and being capable of governing.

836
01:13:47,939 --> 01:13:49,859
And that is really hard.

837
01:13:51,019 --> 01:13:53,858
(Livio Mascarello, CGT, Mayo '68)
It is necessary to understand...

838
01:13:53,859 --> 01:13:57,219
that the scale of the movement,
the power it represents,

839
01:13:58,859 --> 01:14:02,019
means disconcerting the government.

840
01:14:04,139 --> 01:14:06,179
This supposes a problem for them,

841
01:14:06,819 --> 01:14:09,539
though I must say it hasn't reacted yet.

842
01:14:10,339 --> 01:14:13,258
I believe our social-democrat friends...

843
01:14:13,259 --> 01:14:15,739
feel there's a vacuum of power.

844
01:14:16,139 --> 01:14:17,179
It is not so simple.

845
01:14:17,779 --> 01:14:20,779
(May 28 - François Miterrand)
I propose that a provisional government...

846
01:14:22,139 --> 01:14:24,258
and an acting administration...

847
01:14:24,259 --> 01:14:26,299
be formed immediately.

848
01:14:27,779 --> 01:14:29,019
Why is it not so simple?

849
01:14:29,499 --> 01:14:32,659
Why? Because there must be an alternative...

850
01:14:34,259 --> 01:14:36,378
Now the Movement is for...

851
01:14:36,379 --> 01:14:38,939
economical and social change.

852
01:14:39,699 --> 01:14:42,818
So we must offer the working class a solution.

853
01:14:42,819 --> 01:14:45,058
That solution would be a common programme...

854
01:14:45,059 --> 01:14:47,499
of all the forces of the left.

855
01:14:47,819 --> 01:14:48,859
But that doesn't exist.

856
01:14:49,579 --> 01:14:52,378
The forces of the left must carry out...

857
01:14:52,379 --> 01:14:55,219
their responsibilities without delay...

858
01:14:56,019 --> 01:14:59,859
and agree on a minimum programme of government...

859
01:15:00,459 --> 01:15:04,579
that shows the way to a democratic alternative: a popular government.

860
01:15:05,379 --> 01:15:06,499
Today, for example,

861
01:15:07,259 --> 01:15:09,218
the workers are talking...

862
01:15:09,219 --> 01:15:11,739
of a shift of the power to the left.

863
01:15:12,379 --> 01:15:14,659
This sensation comes from the strike committee.

864
01:15:16,099 --> 01:15:17,339
They want to go further now.

865
01:15:17,499 --> 01:15:20,778
(CGT Propaganda Film, 1969)
That's why many workers looked further.

866
01:15:20,779 --> 01:15:22,778
Further?
To start the revolution...

867
01:15:22,779 --> 01:15:25,979
we must change the government.

868
01:15:26,579 --> 01:15:29,899
All we saw was a change in social policy, that's all.

869
01:15:30,899 --> 01:15:33,418
(CGT Delegate, May '68)
They don't want just economical changes,

870
01:15:33,419 --> 01:15:35,099
but also political changes.

871
01:15:35,819 --> 01:15:38,859
They want both things.
They've had enough.

872
01:15:39,539 --> 01:15:41,978
And what's more: the longer it takes...

873
01:15:41,979 --> 01:15:45,939
the stronger will be the determination
of achieving political change.

874
01:15:46,139 --> 01:15:49,799
I spoke with many workers. They feel it is not worth...

875
01:15:49,839 --> 01:15:52,820
making demands that the regime itself will forget.

876
01:15:52,821 --> 01:15:54,859
They want a change, political and economic.

877
01:15:55,019 --> 01:15:57,739
(The Sorbonne)
This is what I see when I speak with the workers.

878
01:15:58,299 --> 01:16:02,018
I believe that we must politicise ourselves the most we can,

879
01:16:02,019 --> 01:16:05,739
Both ourselves and the workers.

880
01:16:08,459 --> 01:16:11,059
(Citroën)
There's only one goal, get rid of the bosses.

881
01:16:17,099 --> 01:16:18,339
How are you going to fire them?
Is that your best joke?

882
01:16:19,459 --> 01:16:22,059
This is the front line!
Everything starts here!

883
01:16:22,739 --> 01:16:25,539
This is the point where life
becomes something big.

884
01:16:25,979 --> 01:16:27,699
When there aren't any more
bosses to sod you up.

885
01:16:29,299 --> 01:16:30,539
This is the demand we have to make.

886
01:16:30,579 --> 01:16:34,819
The bosses don't matter!
Right! We have to start there.

887
01:16:37,499 --> 01:16:40,779
We won't get rid of them with
out voting papers, that's for sure.

888
01:16:41,579 --> 01:16:44,098
Not by voting...
We need someone who knows how to govern.

889
01:16:44,099 --> 01:16:48,379
A lot of people know how to govern!
Look, there's the boss.

890
01:16:52,179 --> 01:16:53,299
I'd vote for you!

891
01:16:54,099 --> 01:16:56,899
While the factory is occupied,
we need a PR man.

892
01:16:58,899 --> 01:17:02,039
Let's forget the meaning of the word 'boss'.
'Boss'? What's that?

893
01:17:03,739 --> 01:17:07,259
The direction of a business,
of a factory,

894
01:17:07,739 --> 01:17:11,859
has become, in the modern world,
in a specialist's domain.

895
01:17:12,259 --> 01:17:16,019
(M. Wolgensinger)
They talk about a company of managers and, truly,

896
01:17:16,819 --> 01:17:20,719
the person who directs the factory today
is the management technician.

897
01:17:20,859 --> 01:17:23,938
Thus, a boss should be a member of the board, and not...

898
01:17:23,939 --> 01:17:26,059
a boss who keeps what we earn.

899
01:17:26,323 --> 01:17:34,287
It saddens us that dialogue is so hard with the unions.

900
01:17:34,941 --> 01:17:43,140
But it happens that they aren't professional unions, but unions...

901
01:17:43,764 --> 01:17:45,798
which are largely politicised.

902
01:17:46,873 --> 01:17:50,864
I ask myself if History will teach us that...

903
01:17:51,751 --> 01:17:56,448
the victories, quantitatively, of the French workers' world...

904
01:17:56,921 --> 01:18:02,122
demands isn't a deviation of its original expression.

905
01:18:02,888 --> 01:18:06,139
(Edgard Pisani)
I think that there's a terrible complicity...

906
01:18:06,529 --> 01:18:11,468
between the conservative apparatus
of the CGT and that of the government.

907
01:18:12,015 --> 01:18:15,497
The CGT is truly the only union for the worker.

908
01:18:17,114 --> 01:18:20,313
As I see it, it is the only union that
has been able to defend a closed position...

909
01:18:21,259 --> 01:18:22,576
article one comes to mind...

910
01:18:23,433 --> 01:18:24,047
What does article one say?

911
01:18:24,048 --> 01:18:25,458
Supression of employers and the wage system.

912
01:18:25,459 --> 01:18:29,858
(May 27, Paris, Charléty Stadium)
The CGT hasn't been able...

913
01:18:29,859 --> 01:18:32,939
or, more likely, hasn't wanted to see...

914
01:18:33,659 --> 01:18:36,499
the real character of this movement.

915
01:18:37,619 --> 01:18:42,859
It's quite obvious, or else the words
no longer have meaning...

916
01:18:43,899 --> 01:18:48,939
that we are going through a
revolutionary movement.

917
01:18:50,819 --> 01:18:52,299
When we look, despite the prohibition...

918
01:18:52,619 --> 01:18:56,219
of the Communist Party and the CGT, at what is happening,

919
01:18:57,139 --> 01:19:00,579
we can honestly say:
Anything is possible!

920
01:19:01,139 --> 01:19:04,819
The battle is on, and we shall go until the end, that's to say,

921
01:19:04,859 --> 01:19:08,179
until the only possible solution:
The socialist revolution!

922
01:19:11,699 --> 01:19:13,698
The French bourgeoisie trusts the Communist Party...

923
01:19:13,699 --> 01:19:16,938
because it hasn't been able to read
the situation and won't go any further.

924
01:19:16,939 --> 01:19:20,299
(Trostkist worker)
Why can't it?
Why, what?

925
01:19:20,579 --> 01:19:22,499
Why can't it go any further, for you?

926
01:19:22,979 --> 01:19:25,978
Because since it exists, since...

927
01:19:25,979 --> 01:19:29,099
the war, maybe before,

928
01:19:29,819 --> 01:19:32,258
its militants got used to think...

929
01:19:32,259 --> 01:19:35,619
according to what the direction decided.

930
01:19:36,339 --> 01:19:38,379
Finally, it was Stalin who destroyed it all.

931
01:19:38,899 --> 01:19:42,059
Trotsky was right: Socialism can't
happen in only one country.

932
01:19:43,179 --> 01:19:44,659
Stalin said it could be done.

933
01:19:46,819 --> 01:19:48,339
Experience shows it has been done.

934
01:19:48,659 --> 01:19:52,019
No, the USSR isn't socialism, not at all.

935
01:19:52,259 --> 01:19:55,139
I believe the capitalist system,

936
01:19:56,819 --> 01:19:58,339
in the traditional sense of the word,

937
01:19:59,259 --> 01:20:03,698
and the communist or, socialist system,

938
01:20:03,699 --> 01:20:05,298
given that the very communists say...

939
01:20:05,299 --> 01:20:08,099
they have a socialist economy,
at least for the moment...

940
01:20:08,779 --> 01:20:12,739
and that communism will come when all problems are solved.

941
01:20:13,339 --> 01:20:17,499
I think these two forms of society are,
right now, antiquated...

942
01:20:18,179 --> 01:20:20,739
and that what we are seeing and will see...

943
01:20:21,379 --> 01:20:24,459
is the construction of new structures...

944
01:20:25,459 --> 01:20:30,619
be they for a socialist or for a, not capitalist, but a liberal economy,

945
01:20:31,419 --> 01:20:34,698
that can come up with solutions...

946
01:20:34,699 --> 01:20:38,858
And, why not, a rapprochement of these two tendencies,

947
01:20:38,859 --> 01:20:42,898
given that, for example, in Russia
today we see...

948
01:20:42,899 --> 01:20:47,139
a complete change in economical policy.

949
01:20:47,579 --> 01:20:50,499
Re-introduction of profit, competition, etc.

950
01:21:06,259 --> 01:21:08,379
Haven't the objectives of
the strikes been forgotten in this kermesse?

951
01:21:10,259 --> 01:21:11,778
No, they aren't forgotten,

952
01:21:11,779 --> 01:21:14,618
But they take place at a different level.

953
01:21:14,619 --> 01:21:18,418
In a different level of that
of the workers.

954
01:21:18,419 --> 01:21:21,219
They know that there are trusted comrades in talks with the bosses...

955
01:21:22,303 --> 01:21:30,583
Before May, there was a whole new critique
to the unions, regarding their submission

956
01:21:32,847 --> 01:21:39,162
May came and everything changed.
They can no longer fight the same way,

957
01:21:39,502 --> 01:21:42,553
They no longer trust this kind of
bureaucracy that has installed itself in,

958
01:21:42,876 --> 01:21:43,652
which they may or may not accept,

959
01:21:44,123 --> 01:21:45,261
and it breaks my heart to say this, but it is true.

960
01:21:46,420 --> 01:21:48,362
If the unions have established negotiations...

961
01:21:48,855 --> 01:21:50,677
then we should know about them, and this...

962
01:21:50,978 --> 01:21:52,609
the lads grumble a lot about this.

963
01:21:53,099 --> 01:21:56,858
(March 1969)
Either way, there was a revolutionary element.

964
01:21:56,859 --> 01:21:58,979
There was something else.

965
01:21:59,539 --> 01:22:04,738
People left our factories without...

966
01:22:04,739 --> 01:22:07,299
even knowing what our demands were.

967
01:22:07,819 --> 01:22:12,298
They all left and the strike took
place under union legality.

968
01:22:12,299 --> 01:22:14,098
I mean, a vote was taken...

969
01:22:14,099 --> 01:22:18,219
The majority voted for the strike.
Everything was perfect.

970
01:22:18,739 --> 01:22:21,779
They went because there was a
general movement to get rid of De Gaulle,

971
01:22:22,299 --> 01:22:23,299
to change all that.

972
01:22:24,259 --> 01:22:26,579
Later, we made notebooks
with our demands.

973
01:22:28,499 --> 01:22:30,898
The people understand perfectly...

974
01:22:30,899 --> 01:22:33,218
that the Grenelle Report,

975
01:22:33,219 --> 01:22:36,458
and I say 'Report' because
people always correct me.

976
01:22:36,459 --> 01:22:40,939
When I say Agreement they say
that it is a Report. Report, then.

977
01:22:42,259 --> 01:22:44,550
There wasn't a Grenelle Agreement, there was a Report.

978
01:22:44,551 --> 01:22:47,259
This Grenelle Report
shut off the movement.

979
01:22:48,259 --> 01:22:50,218
The bourgeoisie played their cards
well, I think.

980
01:22:50,219 --> 01:22:51,939
They felt cornered, so they
made a concession.

981
01:22:53,299 --> 01:22:56,219
They raised the minimum wage.

982
01:22:56,979 --> 01:22:58,298
This mass of people,

983
01:22:58,299 --> 01:23:00,778
who wasn't prepared for
a long political struggle...

984
01:23:00,779 --> 01:23:04,018
because they'd never
talked about it,

985
01:23:04,019 --> 01:23:06,058
found themselves with a raise,

986
01:23:06,059 --> 01:23:08,979
a rather large raise.

987
01:23:09,779 --> 01:23:12,258
The apolitical ones, 2 or 3 millions...

988
01:23:12,259 --> 01:23:14,818
of the 9 million strikers,

989
01:23:14,819 --> 01:23:17,058
couldn't understand why we wanted
to go any further.

990
01:23:17,059 --> 01:23:21,579
They couldn't understand why carry
on the strike.

991
01:23:24,419 --> 01:23:28,099
Specially because they felt nobody
wanted anything more.

992
01:23:29,482 --> 01:23:33,047
It is clear that there were bad
moments in the organizations of the Left.

993
01:23:33,638 --> 01:23:35,732
After 8-10 days a critique was established,

994
01:23:36,789 --> 01:23:38,560
they criticized everything a bit, the student movement,

995
01:23:39,456 --> 01:23:42,878
The students; It was normal they came
with us to certain demonstrations,

996
01:23:43,229 --> 01:23:48,002
but they had a provocative
attitude which wasn't accord...

997
01:23:48,434 --> 01:23:52,804
to the conception the working
class had of the struggle.

998
01:23:53,297 --> 01:23:56,066
We saw them come with helmets, with bats...

999
01:24:01,583 --> 01:24:03,058
Maybe one will always be someone else's leftist.

1000
01:24:03,059 --> 01:24:05,474
(French Newsreel, October 1948)
In Saint-Étienne, however, the CGT strikers,

1001
01:24:05,886 --> 01:24:08,401
shunned by their comrades from the other two unions,

1002
01:24:09,108 --> 01:24:11,805
take to counter-attack and attack the CRS with stones,

1003
01:24:12,178 --> 01:24:13,395
screws, and iron bars.

1004
01:24:27,890 --> 01:24:31,311
(Flins - June 7, 1968)
At the beginning there was a certain malaise, it has to be acknowledged,

1005
01:24:32,146 --> 01:24:34,623
some workers from Renault were convinced by alleged students...

1006
01:24:35,566 --> 01:24:40,781
to face the police forces. They let themselves be fooled,

1007
01:24:41,233 --> 01:24:43,812
they really believed the students would come to help them.

1008
01:24:44,231 --> 01:24:48,893
And I say alleged students, because I saw groups of real students,

1009
01:24:49,910 --> 01:24:52,816
that when the time came to fight, simply left saying:...

1010
01:24:53,434 --> 01:24:57,547
"We haven't come for this, we came to help you, not to fight".

1011
01:24:59,240 --> 01:25:01,051
It was a really well set-up job, eh?

1012
01:25:01,716 --> 01:25:04,170
They had done things well. Health service first of all.

1013
01:25:08,027 --> 01:25:09,799
(June 15 - Burial Gilles Tautin)
There were many workers in front of the cars,

1014
01:25:10,835 --> 01:25:12,336
and they wanted to demonstrate in front of the factory,

1015
01:25:12,986 --> 01:25:14,720
the cops all came out of the factory,

1016
01:25:16,167 --> 01:25:17,497
and pursued them through the fields, well,

1017
01:25:18,123 --> 01:25:20,310
until they halted in the town, and grenade after grenade,

1018
01:25:20,680 --> 01:25:21,633
made us retreat.

1019
01:25:22,319 --> 01:25:23,698
And it was just after midday that they sent...

1020
01:25:24,240 --> 01:25:27,311
(May 'Ciné-Tract')
the guys from Melin. The students. They were taken out of the cars...

1021
01:25:27,703 --> 01:25:30,279
made to get into line and then the police attacked them,

1022
01:25:30,863 --> 01:25:33,138
surrounded them, the boys threw themselves into the Seine so as not to be caught,

1023
01:25:34,949 --> 01:25:37,524
And then they held them from coming back. And the one who took out his gun,

1024
01:25:37,606 --> 01:25:39,993
we nearly lynched him. If the best of the four-eyes hadn't come,

1025
01:25:40,007 --> 01:25:40,990
we'd have lynched him.

1026
01:25:51,419 --> 01:25:53,379
There were elections after the movement.

1027
01:25:53,979 --> 01:25:56,899
They were a defeat for us.
Why a defeat?

1028
01:25:57,819 --> 01:26:00,538
A lot of people were afraid.

1029
01:26:00,539 --> 01:26:02,579
They were very scared.

1030
01:26:03,299 --> 01:26:07,619
What did we show them?
4 or 5 burned cars?

1031
01:26:08,099 --> 01:26:11,418
It isn't a lot, but 4 or 5
in one night,

1032
01:26:11,419 --> 01:26:13,698
even if they were the same 4 the next day...

1033
01:26:13,699 --> 01:26:17,299
They had a lot of TV airtime...

1034
01:26:18,339 --> 01:26:21,338
and, to top it, there was a lot
of pacifist people...

1035
01:26:21,339 --> 01:26:23,978
who weren't to quick to reflect...

1036
01:26:23,979 --> 01:26:26,619
but who got scared with anything...

1037
01:26:27,659 --> 01:26:29,499
like snails who went into theirs shells.

1038
01:26:30,139 --> 01:26:32,099
And that made them panic.

1039
01:26:34,499 --> 01:26:37,818
If anything was threatened violently in May...

1040
01:26:37,819 --> 01:26:40,618
it wasn't them, but the bourgeoisie.

1041
01:26:40,619 --> 01:26:43,619
It was the bosses.
It's quite clear.

1042
01:26:44,899 --> 01:26:47,459
But then they thought that
anarchy had arrived...

1043
01:26:49,459 --> 01:26:53,499
"Will there be food in the shops?"

1044
01:26:53,819 --> 01:26:56,339
It wasn't much, but it was important.

1045
01:26:57,579 --> 01:26:59,898
What was the impression in France...

1046
01:26:59,899 --> 01:27:04,259
when the TV showed cars burning, Paris in flames?

1047
01:27:04,899 --> 01:27:06,939
Burning cars!
A country in ruins!

1048
01:27:07,379 --> 01:27:10,218
Even the Germans,
and I don't like the Germans,

1049
01:27:10,219 --> 01:27:12,739
but even they avoided the
destruction of Paris...

1050
01:27:14,379 --> 01:27:16,778
And now these people come and set fire to it,

1051
01:27:16,779 --> 01:27:19,619
they set fire to the Sorbonne.
It's atrocious!

1052
01:27:20,179 --> 01:27:24,459
They've set fire to the Sorbonne and everywhere.
It's atrocious!

1053
01:27:27,339 --> 01:27:30,339
(Avignon, July)

1054
01:27:30,614 --> 01:27:34,062
The movement has found its main enemy, Jean Vilar,

1055
01:27:35,221 --> 01:27:37,554
and for this occasion, they've come up with a stupid slogan,

1056
01:27:38,389 --> 01:27:40,221
in a time they seemed to compete for those:

1057
01:27:40,389 --> 01:27:42,221
Béjart, Vilar, Salazar

1058
01:27:42,644 --> 01:27:43,201
Béjart!

1059
01:27:43,478 --> 01:27:44,069
Vilar!

1060
01:27:44,412 --> 01:27:45,572
Salazar!

1061
01:28:04,299 --> 01:28:06,539
The work of the Living Theatre
has been played...

1062
01:28:07,259 --> 01:28:08,979
on three successive nights.

1063
01:28:11,219 --> 01:28:16,018
And there have been no demands
to close it down...

1064
01:28:16,019 --> 01:28:18,939
inside the Carmes Cloister.

1065
01:28:26,339 --> 01:28:28,539
And that is all I have to say.

1066
01:28:39,659 --> 01:28:50,539
Down with the bourgeois festival!

1067
01:29:00,619 --> 01:29:02,299
One remembered the solitude of Vilar...

1068
01:29:02,799 --> 01:29:06,478
and asked himself where were all
those people he'd helped...

1069
01:29:06,479 --> 01:29:08,399
and for whose worked he'd fought.

1070
01:29:10,199 --> 01:29:15,444
It was a time of bitterness and madness
of which some would never come out.

1071
01:29:16,119 --> 01:29:17,918
It was a strange way of being
faithful to the spirit of May.

1072
01:29:17,919 --> 01:29:20,919
Giving up so soon and lashing out so blindly...

1073
01:29:21,439 --> 01:29:22,219
against the tricks History played.

1074
01:29:23,522 --> 01:29:26,704
Anyway, History wasn't being written in
Avignon that summer.

1075
01:29:28,420 --> 01:29:29,564
It was being written in Prague.

1076
01:29:31,350 --> 01:29:34,550
END OF THE FIRST PART

1077
01:29:35,347 --> 01:29:37,981
Second Part
THE SEVERED HANDS

1078
01:29:41,661 --> 01:29:45,540
(French Newsreel, May 1945)
In Europe, Prague was one of the first victims of nazi rapacity.

1079
01:29:46,580 --> 01:29:49,180
These images give testimony of the last days of occupation...

1080
01:29:49,900 --> 01:29:54,620
when the Czech capital liberated itself, like Paris, on early May.

1081
01:30:18,858 --> 01:30:20,778
In every country of the world, except in Germany,

1082
01:30:21,338 --> 01:30:24,538
the paving stones were converted in the barricades of freedom.

1083
01:30:27,538 --> 01:30:31,378
In Prague, the archives of the Gestapo were thrown into the sewers...

1084
01:30:31,898 --> 01:30:34,058
and the hook-cross was thrown into the fire.

1085
01:30:38,537 --> 01:30:41,056
(Soviet Newsreel, May 1945)
Our tanks...

1086
01:30:41,057 --> 01:30:43,617
are pushing South; it is the last campaign in the war.

1087
01:30:44,257 --> 01:30:48,857
They approach the enemy, who still fights.

1088
01:30:56,096 --> 01:30:59,936
The salvation of Prague depends on their speed.

1089
01:31:00,736 --> 01:31:03,016
One hour more supposes 100.000 lives.

1090
01:31:04,816 --> 01:31:08,976
The first Soviet tank that entered free Prague carried the number 23.

1091
01:31:09,815 --> 01:31:12,215
It was the same tank, now a monument,

1092
01:31:12,495 --> 01:31:16,215
that was surround by other Russian tanks in August 1968.

1093
01:31:16,816 --> 01:31:19,816
FROM THE PRAGUE SPRING
TO THE COMMON PROGRAMME

1094
01:31:29,454 --> 01:31:31,733
In a wall in Bratislava one can read:

1095
01:31:31,734 --> 01:31:35,014
"Lenin, wake up. Brezhnev has gone mad".

1096
01:31:35,054 --> 01:31:38,133
Everywhere clandestine radio stations transmit non-stop.

1097
01:31:38,134 --> 01:31:41,293
But the most significant message of August 21...

1098
01:31:41,294 --> 01:31:43,354
was the one summoning all delegates...

1099
01:31:43,364 --> 01:31:44,833
of the XIV Congress of the Czechoslovak Communist Party.

1100
01:31:44,860 --> 01:31:47,396
The delegates are taken by car to a factory...

1101
01:31:47,920 --> 01:31:49,819
in a working-class quarter were the congress is held.

1102
01:31:50,453 --> 01:31:52,813
The most recognisable are taken in trucks or ambulances.

1103
01:31:54,314 --> 01:31:58,114
A clandestine camera has preserved the images of this clandestine congress.

1104
01:32:01,812 --> 01:32:03,612
Let me emphasise what we see here:

1105
01:32:04,132 --> 01:32:07,732
This is not an improvised manifestation, however numerous.

1106
01:32:08,452 --> 01:32:11,052
This is the legal expression of the Czechoslovak Communist Party.

1107
01:32:11,453 --> 01:32:13,853
A congress called by the Central Committee from June 1st.

1108
01:32:14,216 --> 01:32:17,353
With delegates elected according to the rules during the months of June and July.

1109
01:32:17,354 --> 01:32:19,651
And, despite the change of date, accelerated by the Russian invasion,

1110
01:32:20,011 --> 01:32:21,991
1182 delegates are present.

1111
01:32:22,071 --> 01:32:24,691
That is, 3/4 of the entire organisation.

1112
01:32:25,211 --> 01:32:28,450
So, according to the statutes, the congress...

1113
01:32:28,451 --> 01:32:31,641
is, for the moment, the only organism with legitimacy to lead the Party.

1114
01:32:31,651 --> 01:32:34,491
First orator: Vaculik.
The main reality...

1115
01:32:34,531 --> 01:32:38,090
is that of the occupation of the Republic by allied troops.

1116
01:32:38,650 --> 01:32:41,689
A occupation decided without the consent of our president,

1117
01:32:41,690 --> 01:32:43,830
our government, Assembly, or Central Committee.

1118
01:32:43,850 --> 01:32:47,810
Next question: the unanimous reaction of our peoples against the occupation.

1119
01:32:48,530 --> 01:32:52,369
This unanimous reaction is, to my eyes, the only decisive sign...

1120
01:32:52,370 --> 01:32:56,649
that the Party should take into account regarding what attitude it should assume.

1121
01:32:56,661 --> 01:33:00,051
If we want to be loyal to the compromise of our people we cannot express ourselves otherwise.

1122
01:33:00,929 --> 01:33:03,809
We'll never be friends of the USSR again!

1123
01:33:05,529 --> 01:33:07,969
It's 'autumn leaves'. Wet paper.

1124
01:33:11,448 --> 01:33:13,048
We've waited...

1125
01:33:13,888 --> 01:33:18,207
We've had faith for 20 years,

1126
01:33:18,208 --> 01:33:21,248
100 years. It's too much.

1127
01:33:26,447 --> 01:33:30,516
Brezhnev arrives on July 29 to Cierna nad Tisou, Slovakia, in his special train...

1128
01:33:31,358 --> 01:33:33,550
having spent the night crossing Soviet territory.

1129
01:33:34,543 --> 01:33:37,139
There were many embraces, but the final communiqué was still vague.

1130
01:33:37,973 --> 01:33:40,788
Brezhnev and Dubcek no longer gave words the same meaning.

1131
01:33:42,543 --> 01:33:51,094
Dubcek goes to Moscow and finds another Brezhnev who threatens with military invasion and 'normalization'.

1132
01:33:51,768 --> 01:33:53,649
We could ask ourselves why Dubcek and those with him...

1133
01:33:54,241 --> 01:33:56,909
were given the relative honour of sitting at a negotiation table...

1134
01:33:57,581 --> 01:34:00,167
without the presence of the President of the Republic, Svoboda,

1135
01:34:00,651 --> 01:34:05,096
who goes to Moscow of his own initiative in search of the abducted members of the Central Committee.

1136
01:34:09,272 --> 01:34:13,381
Brezhnev welcomes him as though it all was a show of Czech-Soviet friendship...

1137
01:34:13,946 --> 01:34:16,380
and they parade through the streets of Moscow...

1138
01:34:16,895 --> 01:34:19,450
three days before the troops of the Warsaw Pact invade Czechoslovakia.

1139
01:34:47,323 --> 01:34:48,923
BROTHERS!

1140
01:34:49,003 --> 01:34:53,162
What are you doing in Prague?

1141
01:34:53,163 --> 01:34:56,136
And you call yourself a communist?

1142
01:34:57,136 --> 01:34:59,730
(Havana, August 23, 1968)
Some things we'll say, in some cases...

1143
01:35:02,008 --> 01:35:05,444
will be in contradiction...

1144
01:35:08,414 --> 01:35:10,678
with the emotions of many.

1145
01:35:13,151 --> 01:35:18,715
In other cases, they will be in contradiction...

1146
01:35:19,291 --> 01:35:21,384
with our own interests.

1147
01:35:24,596 --> 01:35:26,223
And in others...

1148
01:35:27,366 --> 01:35:30,664
will constitute grave perils...

1149
01:35:30,935 --> 01:35:32,596
to our country.

1150
01:35:34,271 --> 01:35:35,966
We believe that...

1151
01:35:36,407 --> 01:35:38,568
the decision taken in Czechoslovakia,

1152
01:35:38,876 --> 01:35:40,673
can only be explained,

1153
01:35:41,345 --> 01:35:44,508
from a political point of view,

1154
01:35:44,782 --> 01:35:48,444
not a legal point of view,

1155
01:35:50,654 --> 01:35:52,622
because as far as legality is concerned,

1156
01:35:52,889 --> 01:35:56,416
it has frankly none!

1157
01:36:02,065 --> 01:36:04,726
What circumstance have led to...

1158
01:36:05,034 --> 01:36:07,559
a remedy of such nature?

1159
01:36:09,071 --> 01:36:12,507
A remedy that places the international...

1160
01:36:12,771 --> 01:36:16,507
revolutionary movement in a difficult situation.

1161
01:36:18,313 --> 01:36:21,907
A remedy which creates a truly traumatic situation...

1162
01:36:22,183 --> 01:36:26,643
for a people, such as the situation of the Czechoslovak people.

1163
01:36:28,656 --> 01:36:31,420
Which forces an entire people...

1164
01:36:32,326 --> 01:36:34,294
to go through the thankless...

1165
01:36:34,562 --> 01:36:38,520
situation of seeing...

1166
01:36:38,832 --> 01:36:43,292
its country occupied by the armies of other countries,

1167
01:36:44,004 --> 01:36:48,304
though they may be socialist.

1168
01:36:48,775 --> 01:36:52,871
This situation that makes millions of citizens of a country...

1169
01:36:54,214 --> 01:36:58,115
in the tragic dilemma of choosing to be...

1170
01:36:59,585 --> 01:37:03,783
either passive in this situation,

1171
01:37:04,056 --> 01:37:08,322
which reminds them of previous events,

1172
01:37:09,628 --> 01:37:13,688
or to opt for the fight, side by side,

1173
01:37:13,965 --> 01:37:18,265
with pro-American agents,

1174
01:37:19,070 --> 01:37:22,198
with enemies of socialism,

1175
01:37:22,507 --> 01:37:25,806
with West-German spies,

1176
01:37:26,111 --> 01:37:29,171
and all this fascist and reactionary rabble...

1177
01:37:29,447 --> 01:37:31,505
which under these circumstances...

1178
01:37:31,782 --> 01:37:35,183
will try to present themselves as...

1179
01:37:35,452 --> 01:37:38,819
patriots and freedom-fighters for Czechoslovak liberty.

1180
01:37:42,960 --> 01:37:46,225
But the essential thing, which may be accepted or not,

1181
01:37:46,964 --> 01:37:50,729
is this: Could the socialist bloc allow...

1182
01:37:53,069 --> 01:37:55,765
the development of a political situation...

1183
01:37:56,305 --> 01:37:59,297
which led to the split...

1184
01:37:59,842 --> 01:38:02,037
of a socialist country...

1185
01:38:02,345 --> 01:38:06,944
and its fall in the arms of imperialism?

1186
01:38:08,183 --> 01:38:12,176
Our view is: it couldn't have allowed it.

1187
01:38:12,988 --> 01:38:15,320
And the socialist bloc has the right...

1188
01:38:15,624 --> 01:38:19,025
to prevent it, one way or another.

1189
01:38:19,191 --> 01:38:20,430
(Georges Marchais, Secretary General of the French Communist Party)

1190
01:38:20,431 --> 01:38:23,270
(Lille, 1970)
The French Communist Party...

1191
01:38:24,270 --> 01:38:26,150
has declared its opposition to the invasion...

1192
01:38:27,270 --> 01:38:28,550
and that position has not changed.

1193
01:38:29,390 --> 01:38:32,430
It was reaffirmed in our XIXth Congress.

1194
01:38:35,390 --> 01:38:39,190
I can resume the reasons of this position in three phrases:

1195
01:38:41,469 --> 01:38:44,829
In January 1968, when the Czechoslovak Communist Party...

1196
01:38:45,549 --> 01:38:49,509
pronounced itself for the economical changes in the country...

1197
01:38:51,509 --> 01:38:54,549
for the application of a real socialist democracy...

1198
01:38:55,909 --> 01:38:57,907
while it would affect in no way its internal affairs,

1199
01:38:57,908 --> 01:39:02,628
we found that perspective to be fair and we supported it.

1200
01:39:04,228 --> 01:39:07,427
However, it is evident that in a country like Czechoslovakia...

1201
01:39:07,428 --> 01:39:10,508
which has been socialist for only 25 years,

1202
01:39:11,268 --> 01:39:16,747
it is necessary to fight against forces hostile to socialism.

1203
01:39:18,187 --> 01:39:20,067
But we, as we always believed...

1204
01:39:21,387 --> 01:39:25,427
thought that the Czech Communist Party and the democratic Czech workers...

1205
01:39:26,227 --> 01:39:29,687
were strong enough to solve this problem themselves.

1206
01:39:29,987 --> 01:39:32,065
It was the first time that a list of candidates...

1207
01:39:32,066 --> 01:39:34,706
for a conference hadn't been prepared beforehand.

1208
01:39:35,226 --> 01:39:38,486
Anyone present could take part in the proceeding.

1209
01:39:38,506 --> 01:39:41,306
Any delegate was free to challenge the orator.

1210
01:39:41,866 --> 01:39:44,546
You've just said 'we'. I can say 'we', too.

1211
01:39:45,426 --> 01:39:48,746
We are all delegates here, and it's up to us to reach an agreement.

1212
01:39:52,882 --> 01:39:55,510
(Etienne Fajon)
Roger Garaudy does his utmost to deform these realities. In his most recent writings...

1213
01:39:56,457 --> 01:40:00,280
In his more recent writings, the prodigious work...

1214
01:40:00,654 --> 01:40:04,454
of the Soviet Union is reduced to a series of mistakes,

1215
01:40:05,836 --> 01:40:09,072
Only the October Revolution is valid to his eyes,

1216
01:40:10,152 --> 01:40:15,531
and the solidarity with the CPSU is replaced by the denunciation of the Party...

1217
01:40:16,217 --> 01:40:21,595
and the systematic and often injurious critique of its leaders.

1218
01:40:21,994 --> 01:40:26,340
He undertakes against the USSR and the socialist countries, it must be said,

1219
01:40:27,154 --> 01:40:29,107
the reaction's calumny.

1220
01:40:31,072 --> 01:40:35,498
(Jorge Semprún)
It isn't a Party disciplined in a military way that takes power...

1221
01:40:35,543 --> 01:40:41,302
in October 1917. It's a Party where there was freedom of expression...

1222
01:40:41,342 --> 01:40:44,702
freedom of association, of discussion between fractions.

1223
01:40:45,102 --> 01:40:47,182
All of it while it took the power.

1224
01:40:47,942 --> 01:40:50,301
It was much later, after the victory,

1225
01:40:50,302 --> 01:40:53,181
that this clash of opinions was...

1226
01:40:53,182 --> 01:40:55,582
codified as impossible inside the Party.

1227
01:40:55,782 --> 01:40:57,221
But the Party that took the power...

1228
01:40:57,222 --> 01:41:01,341
was not the model of Party imposed in the entire world.

1229
01:41:01,821 --> 01:41:04,221
Such Party, today, would be expelled...

1230
01:41:05,461 --> 01:41:07,101
from the Communist workers' movement...

1231
01:41:07,501 --> 01:41:09,940
for the very same reasons
why the members...

1232
01:41:09,941 --> 01:41:12,060
of the Czech Communist Party who tried...

1233
01:41:12,061 --> 01:41:14,661
to retake this fight were expelled...

1234
01:41:15,301 --> 01:41:17,059
All members of the Central Committee...

1235
01:41:17,060 --> 01:41:19,620
elected during the congress will be expelled from the Party.

1236
01:41:20,420 --> 01:41:23,780
The XIVth Congress itself will be declared null and void.

1237
01:41:23,781 --> 01:41:24,781
Dubcek in Moscow will have to finish the operation of exorcism.

1238
01:41:26,580 --> 01:41:28,260
So, look well at these images.

1239
01:41:28,980 --> 01:41:31,300
They show something which, apparently, never happened.

1240
01:41:32,140 --> 01:41:35,219
A Communist Party, which, moving away from Stalinism,

1241
01:41:35,779 --> 01:41:38,898
transforms and reinvents itself in socialist democracy...

1242
01:41:38,899 --> 01:41:41,539
something the reactionaries would say is impossible.

1243
01:41:41,579 --> 01:41:43,899
An opinion shared by the Soviets.

1244
01:41:44,159 --> 01:41:45,299
This must be what they call Peaceful Coexistence.

1245
01:41:47,679 --> 01:41:52,038
(Emil Zatopek)

1246
01:42:55,275 --> 01:42:57,634
Recording of Zatopek in 1952, in Helsinki,

1247
01:42:57,635 --> 01:43:00,914
A small island of peace in the Cold War,

1248
01:43:01,074 --> 01:43:03,393
that one day will be seen by historians as...

1249
01:43:03,394 --> 01:43:06,874
the first attempt to cross the abyss between East and West,

1250
01:43:07,114 --> 01:43:08,954
before the turns of ping-pong and basketball diplomacy started,

1251
01:43:10,674 --> 01:43:14,474
At a moment when the War in Korea seemed to predict a very different future.

1252
01:43:19,233 --> 01:43:21,232
There was a team from South Korea in Helsinki,

1253
01:43:21,233 --> 01:43:23,913
and its cook was the man Leni Riefenstahl had filmed,

1254
01:43:24,353 --> 01:43:26,792
as winner of the marathon...

1255
01:43:26,793 --> 01:43:28,993
In the Berlin Olympics of 1936.

1256
01:43:29,673 --> 01:43:31,553
Just that, by then, he was Japanese.

1257
01:43:32,313 --> 01:43:33,833
You never know what you are filming.

1258
01:43:34,872 --> 01:43:38,792
Leni Riefenstahl thought that she was filming a Japanese, and it was a Korean.

1259
01:43:40,112 --> 01:43:43,952
In '52 I thought I was filming the winning rider of the Chilean team.

1260
01:43:43,953 --> 01:43:44,953
I was filming a putschist.

1261
01:43:45,012 --> 01:43:46,832
Turns out it was Lieutenant Mendoza,

1262
01:43:47,352 --> 01:43:49,112
later General Mendoza,

1263
01:43:49,672 --> 01:43:51,112
member of Pinochet's Junta.

1264
01:43:52,311 --> 01:43:53,831
You never know what you are filming.

1265
01:43:58,391 --> 01:44:00,190
What did they say the cameras thought...

1266
01:44:00,191 --> 01:44:02,191
they were showing at the Stadium in Munich 1972?

1267
01:44:02,991 --> 01:44:05,230
Astonishment to see the games...

1268
01:44:05,231 --> 01:44:07,871
carry on despite the death of 8 Israelis?

1269
01:44:08,750 --> 01:44:12,430
But in Mexico City in 1968 I'd seen 200 people massacred...

1270
01:44:13,350 --> 01:44:14,830
so that the Games could begin.

1271
01:44:53,848 --> 01:44:57,408
Student demonstration, May '68, quickly repressed the Mexican way.

1272
01:44:57,768 --> 01:45:01,767
Two hundred dead, and the Games opened in a pacified capital.

1273
01:45:02,287 --> 01:45:05,127
Not a single country turned down the invitation.

1274
01:45:21,766 --> 01:45:25,646
Was it because of this, this nightmare of History, as someone called it,

1275
01:45:26,166 --> 01:45:28,206
that in the Munich Stadium in 1972...

1276
01:45:29,086 --> 01:45:30,846
Emil Zatopek cried?

1277
01:45:36,325 --> 01:45:39,405
Or was it, more precisely, was he back
at the Helsinki stadium in 1952...

1278
01:45:40,365 --> 01:45:44,045
which, for the Czechs, was more than anything, the year of the Slánsky trials?

1279
01:45:45,005 --> 01:45:49,365
Defendant Slánsky, after 30 years in the Czech Party,

1280
01:45:50,005 --> 01:45:53,604
what made you put yourself at the service of the imperialists...

1281
01:45:54,204 --> 01:45:56,643
and direct the conspiracy against the Popular Republic?

1282
01:45:56,644 --> 01:46:02,404
(Rudolf Slánsky. 14 months earlier Secretary General of the Czechoslovak Communist Party)

1283
01:46:04,699 --> 01:46:06,860
To explain myself,

1284
01:46:07,134 --> 01:46:10,227
I must say a few things about my past.

1285
01:46:10,503 --> 01:46:13,836
I did take part...

1286
01:46:16,610 --> 01:46:19,909
in the workers' movement,

1287
01:46:20,380 --> 01:46:22,610
but I come from a bourgeois background.

1288
01:46:24,123 --> 01:46:25,803
Eleven death sentences.

1289
01:46:26,643 --> 01:46:27,962
The first, Slánsky's.

1290
01:46:29,402 --> 01:46:33,482
Three life sentences minus the time spent in jail during trial...

1291
01:46:34,602 --> 01:46:39,522
to Vavro Hajdu, Eugen Löbl
and Arthur London.

1292
01:46:41,162 --> 01:46:43,562
The questions they asked astonished me.

1293
01:46:44,402 --> 01:46:47,201
(Arthur London)
And the answers they tried to obtain by force...

1294
01:46:47,881 --> 01:46:53,481
The questions were identical to the ones in the Rajk process...

1295
01:46:54,161 --> 01:46:56,841
and, some time after, on the Kostov process.

1296
01:46:57,321 --> 01:46:59,320
Afterwards, I remembered the Moscow trials...

1297
01:46:59,321 --> 01:47:03,279
when we had felt so annoyed seeing...

1298
01:47:03,280 --> 01:47:06,799
Lenin's comrades on the benches of infamy.

1299
01:47:06,800 --> 01:47:09,920
We couldn't understand it then, and we felt ill.

1300
01:47:10,320 --> 01:47:11,360
These things coma back...

1301
01:47:11,960 --> 01:47:14,839
And I realised that the process, the whole drama...

1302
01:47:14,840 --> 01:47:17,039
in which I had taken part...

1303
01:47:17,040 --> 01:47:22,839
was the repetition of these trials that had taken place in Moscow.

1304
01:47:22,879 --> 01:47:25,359
That it was all a show.

1305
01:47:27,519 --> 01:47:30,278
Something inherent to the Stalinist...

1306
01:47:30,279 --> 01:47:32,959
system of the '30s.

1307
01:47:34,039 --> 01:47:36,398
By using the term 'Stalinist', doesn't one risk...

1308
01:47:36,438 --> 01:47:39,237
sealing it historically...

1309
01:47:39,238 --> 01:47:41,797
and restrict it to a series...

1310
01:47:41,798 --> 01:47:45,557
of historical, geographical and social circumstances...

1311
01:47:45,558 --> 01:47:47,078
of a given country at a given age?

1312
01:47:47,518 --> 01:47:49,037
Or is it a permanent danger...

1313
01:47:49,038 --> 01:47:51,318
which has to be fought at all times?

1314
01:47:51,878 --> 01:47:55,397
It is a permanent danger, which is all the more dangerous...

1315
01:47:56,037 --> 01:47:59,237
because it hasn't been examined in depth.

1316
01:48:02,597 --> 01:48:03,597
Stalinism...

1317
01:48:05,277 --> 01:48:09,557
has been a grave deformity...

1318
01:48:11,516 --> 01:48:12,636
of socialism.

1319
01:48:16,476 --> 01:48:19,955
Deformity which has had extremely...

1320
01:48:19,956 --> 01:48:22,436
painful consequences...

1321
01:48:25,396 --> 01:48:29,995
for the Soviet people...
and for communists around the world.

1322
01:48:30,315 --> 01:48:31,355
It's an ambiguous term...

1323
01:48:31,995 --> 01:48:34,675
because, it supposes, that, to start with,

1324
01:48:34,795 --> 01:48:36,954
that evolution is connected...

1325
01:48:36,955 --> 01:48:39,595
to a man, or a group of men,

1326
01:48:40,755 --> 01:48:45,035
and maybe, perhaps, a social situation of isolation and regression.

1327
01:48:45,994 --> 01:48:47,753
In such a way that, once a certain kind...

1328
01:48:47,754 --> 01:48:50,314
of leader has left the scene of History,

1329
01:48:51,074 --> 01:48:53,153
and a certain kind of isolation...

1330
01:48:53,154 --> 01:48:56,674
and regression have left the scene of History,

1331
01:48:56,994 --> 01:48:58,874
these phenomena won't happen again.

1332
01:48:59,634 --> 01:49:02,114
But experience shows that that is not exactly right.

1333
01:49:02,794 --> 01:49:05,233
Let's look at Czechoslovakia:

1334
01:49:05,913 --> 01:49:08,353
A developed country,

1335
01:49:09,193 --> 01:49:12,992
a country with a working class, with a long democratic tradition,

1336
01:49:12,993 --> 01:49:16,473
with a long tradition of struggles of all kinds,

1337
01:49:17,073 --> 01:49:21,112
with an authentic Communist Party,

1338
01:49:21,152 --> 01:49:24,351
which doesn't depend on foreign intervention or foreign orders.

1339
01:49:24,352 --> 01:49:27,711
Even there it was possible to impose a certain model...

1340
01:49:27,712 --> 01:49:29,912
which we'll call, to keep it simple, Stalinist.

1341
01:49:30,552 --> 01:49:32,552
Thus, apart from historical,

1342
01:49:33,072 --> 01:49:36,112
geographical and economic reasons,

1343
01:49:36,672 --> 01:49:43,071
we must find a supplementary reason, to use a fashionable word,

1344
01:49:43,671 --> 01:49:45,071
which overdetermines the others.

1345
01:49:45,711 --> 01:49:49,071
I think that we must look for this phenomenon ...

1346
01:49:49,671 --> 01:49:53,591
of overdetermination in the very working mechanism of the institutions of power

1347
01:49:53,871 --> 01:49:56,510
and the Party institutions.

1348
01:49:57,190 --> 01:49:59,270
(Jean Eillenstein, Historian, member of the French Communist Party)

1349
01:49:59,280 --> 01:50:04,589
The French CP, from 1944 to 1953 was undoubtedly Stalinist...

1350
01:50:04,590 --> 01:50:06,989
We must recognise that we were all Stalinists.

1351
01:50:06,990 --> 01:50:11,549
Thousands of French Communists were Stalinists at the time.

1352
01:50:11,550 --> 01:50:16,669
But, what is this we call 'Stalinism'?

1353
01:50:16,989 --> 01:50:18,708
Stalinism, first of all,

1354
01:50:18,709 --> 01:50:23,589
supposes that the USSR is the first socialist State.

1355
01:50:24,229 --> 01:50:27,748
And that it defended and built socialism...

1356
01:50:27,749 --> 01:50:30,348
under historically horrendous conditions.

1357
01:50:30,868 --> 01:50:33,107
I think that, in moments of crisis and action,

1358
01:50:33,108 --> 01:50:35,268
everything easilly turns black and white.

1359
01:50:35,828 --> 01:50:39,668
In those times, a critical thinking can delay necessary action.

1360
01:50:40,148 --> 01:50:44,388
But I believe that it is vital no to let it become a norm.

1361
01:50:44,428 --> 01:50:48,146
Because the lack and destruction of critical thinking...

1362
01:50:48,147 --> 01:50:51,106
always ends up turning against the cause...

1363
01:50:51,107 --> 01:50:53,266
which is defended with abnegation.

1364
01:50:53,267 --> 01:50:57,546
I believe there is, in the tradition of the workers and communist movements,

1365
01:50:57,547 --> 01:51:02,067
a long-term deformity...

1366
01:51:02,547 --> 01:51:05,946
which equals political and military comparisons.

1367
01:51:06,866 --> 01:51:09,065
What I mean is, in a military structure, the orders...

1368
01:51:09,066 --> 01:51:10,986
(April, 1975)
go from the Staff to the troops.

1369
01:51:11,946 --> 01:51:14,065
Rankless soldiers are mere executors...

1370
01:51:14,066 --> 01:51:16,266
(24th Congress of the CPSU)
of the received orders,
the given plans,

1371
01:51:16,786 --> 01:51:19,345
They never take part in the joint discussion...

1372
01:51:19,346 --> 01:51:21,865
of strategical plans.

1373
01:51:23,065 --> 01:51:27,664
It's hard to imagine an army assembled to democratically voted...

1374
01:51:27,665 --> 01:51:31,265
the decisions taken by the commanders or the HQ.

1375
01:51:31,705 --> 01:51:35,265
It's unthinkable, for good or for evil, unthinkable.

1376
01:51:35,785 --> 01:51:37,145
And as far as political action is concerned,

1377
01:51:37,905 --> 01:51:41,663
all attempts of reproducing this model is ill-fated ...

1378
01:51:41,664 --> 01:51:42,824
for political action.

1379
01:51:43,104 --> 01:51:46,143
Thus, the radical difference is that a mass political action...

1380
01:51:46,144 --> 01:51:49,303
cannot be conceived without a constant dialectic...

1381
01:51:49,304 --> 01:51:52,824
which destroys constantly the understanding between the base and the head...

1382
01:51:53,304 --> 01:51:55,224
and that creates a new understanding at every moment.

1383
01:51:55,464 --> 01:52:00,583
Or: the base's, the masses' initiative in politics...

1384
01:52:00,623 --> 01:52:06,022
must act as a impulsive force at all levels:

1385
01:52:06,023 --> 01:52:09,943
union, political, committee, at a workers' democracy level,

1386
01:52:10,503 --> 01:52:13,622
in a way that it constitutes itself in a new impulse...

1387
01:52:13,662 --> 01:52:16,461
and that this impulse goes back to the masses.

1388
01:52:16,462 --> 01:52:19,422
(IX Congress of the Chinese Communist Party, April 1st, 1969)

1389
01:52:20,822 --> 01:52:21,941
Chairman Mao...

1390
01:52:21,942 --> 01:52:27,702
and his close comrade-at-arms,
Lin Piao, leave the stage.

1391
01:52:28,422 --> 01:52:29,702
The crowd cheers.

1392
01:53:07,739 --> 01:53:09,299
LETTER TO SOME COMRADES

1393
01:53:10,619 --> 01:53:11,899
You've dreamt your China.

1394
01:53:15,819 --> 01:53:20,059
Apparently, you have to wash the dishes of this revolution,

1395
01:53:20,259 --> 01:53:24,458
so that it looks immaculate, explainable.

1396
01:53:26,578 --> 01:53:28,258
Everything else will be done without you.

1397
01:53:30,098 --> 01:53:34,178
You found your use there: explain, explain everything.

1398
01:53:35,618 --> 01:53:38,337
Wasn't it enough for you that human history, as it is,

1399
01:53:38,338 --> 01:53:40,817
with its horrors and dark patches,

1400
01:53:41,577 --> 01:53:44,656
took away 700 million people...

1401
01:53:44,657 --> 01:53:46,977
from misery and slavery,

1402
01:53:47,017 --> 01:53:49,056
even though it may be through new servitudes,

1403
01:53:49,057 --> 01:53:52,617
against which a new wave of History stirs and fights?

1404
01:53:53,537 --> 01:53:56,697
No, it all has to be satisfied at once.

1405
01:53:59,036 --> 01:54:01,596
Political theory, democracy, philosophy,

1406
01:54:02,076 --> 01:54:03,716
even art and literature.

1407
01:54:07,176 --> 01:54:09,776
Good. Even if you skip the contradictions...

1408
01:54:10,776 --> 01:54:14,216
you don't do much in the perpetual struggle between the two lines.

1409
01:54:16,335 --> 01:54:17,975
But it is always deciphered in retrospective,

1410
01:54:17,995 --> 01:54:20,135
and from the victor's point of view.

1411
01:54:21,395 --> 01:54:26,015
You practice an inverse form of dialectics, which start at the end,

1412
01:54:26,095 --> 01:54:29,374
or what's the same, the position of the dominating faction,

1413
01:54:29,375 --> 01:54:32,374
and return to a, until now, imperceptible origin.

1414
01:54:34,774 --> 01:54:38,014
Each crisis gave birth not only to a new future,

1415
01:54:38,194 --> 01:54:39,274
but to a new past...

1416
01:54:40,694 --> 01:54:42,854
perfectly clear, though a bit tedious.

1417
01:54:44,214 --> 01:54:46,654
Humble and naive people resisted their own way:

1418
01:54:48,654 --> 01:54:50,353
Naively... humbly.

1419
01:54:52,073 --> 01:54:53,743
Not you.

1420
01:54:53,753 --> 01:54:55,853
Your intelligence was reaffirmed by liars.

1421
01:54:56,973 --> 01:54:59,753
You feel the vertigo of stupidity and leave...

1422
01:54:59,763 --> 01:55:01,453
the real climbers to face the real vertigo...

1423
01:55:02,293 --> 01:55:04,173
with a feeling of pride and victory.

1424
01:55:10,092 --> 01:55:13,172
By explaining it all, by justifying it all,

1425
01:55:14,052 --> 01:55:18,412
you side with the more traditional role that tyranny has assigned intellectuals.

1426
01:55:19,172 --> 01:55:21,012
Your sole originality...

1427
01:55:21,492 --> 01:55:25,011
consists in that you did while you proclaimed the end of tyranny...

1428
01:55:26,011 --> 01:55:28,571
and while you persuaded yourself you had worked to destroy it.

1429
01:55:42,650 --> 01:55:46,050
Georges Pompidou, President of France who'd soon be dead,

1430
01:55:46,490 --> 01:55:49,970
meets Jian Qing, wife of Mao Tse-Tung, who'd soon be a widow.

1431
01:55:51,570 --> 01:55:55,330
On the doorstep of the Great Helmsman, Pompidou is welcomed by Wang Hong-Wen,

1432
01:55:56,090 --> 01:55:59,248
promoted by the Cultural Revolution to the heights of the Central Committee...

1433
01:55:59,249 --> 01:56:01,449
to represent it symbolically.

1434
01:56:03,789 --> 01:56:07,929
At this time, Mao is the last of this special kind of men...

1435
01:56:08,029 --> 01:56:11,148
who reign no so much because they impose their will,

1436
01:56:11,149 --> 01:56:12,669
even if they do impose a lot,

1437
01:56:13,389 --> 01:56:14,749
but because they incarnate something.

1438
01:56:15,829 --> 01:56:17,987
This has to do with a need to believe,

1439
01:56:17,988 --> 01:56:20,348
of having faith, the fear of the void, of the paternal figure.

1440
01:56:21,668 --> 01:56:25,228
All this does not represent the most comforting possibility of man...

1441
01:56:25,868 --> 01:56:27,748
but is the stuff with which dreams are made.

1442
01:56:29,268 --> 01:56:30,948
The right thing here is to think there's a slight miscasting.

1443
01:56:31,668 --> 01:56:35,587
It was De Gaulle who should have met Mao. At least, that's what History wanted.

1444
01:56:36,427 --> 01:56:38,547
But History gets old...

1445
01:56:39,347 --> 01:56:41,587
and loses sight, and can be tricked easily.

1446
01:56:43,734 --> 01:56:48,475
Specially if one is a child of the elites and moreover stimulated by ingratitude.

1447
01:56:49,524 --> 01:56:52,051
I don't think I have what is called a 'political future'.

1448
01:56:52,706 --> 01:56:54,760
(Georges Pompidou, February 1969)
I have a political past.

1449
01:56:54,761 --> 01:56:58,596
I may have, God willing, a national destiny.

1450
01:56:59,790 --> 01:57:02,905
Thus begins the war of sucession, in China as in France.

1451
01:57:03,944 --> 01:57:09,893
With the complicity, bitter or ironic, or so it seems, of those that were to be succeeded.

1452
01:57:10,885 --> 01:57:14,364
(Maurice Grimaud)
I saw him at the end of June...

1453
01:57:14,365 --> 01:57:16,685
and he was a different man.

1454
01:57:17,365 --> 01:57:21,204
He seemed exhausted and obviously insecure about his future...

1455
01:57:21,205 --> 01:57:23,724
even though he'd won the match after the 30th of May,

1456
01:57:23,725 --> 01:57:25,404
and had managed to revert the situation.

1457
01:57:26,164 --> 01:57:28,843
But General De Gaulle had been clearly...

1458
01:57:28,844 --> 01:57:31,964
touched by the events.

1459
01:57:32,684 --> 01:57:36,324
And many of his most loyal men were...

1460
01:57:36,884 --> 01:57:38,964
thinking of abandoning him.

1461
01:57:39,484 --> 01:57:41,163
They thought that he had become a...

1462
01:57:41,164 --> 01:57:43,603
bothersome figure and abandoned him.

1463
01:57:44,843 --> 01:57:46,962
(Alain Touraine)
The left had...

1464
01:57:46,963 --> 01:57:49,283
joined De Gaulle during the events of May and June...

1465
01:57:49,803 --> 01:57:52,083
and it was the right that got rid of him in April.

1466
01:57:52,523 --> 01:57:56,923
An analysis of the results of the referendum is quite clear on this.

1467
01:57:57,723 --> 01:58:02,041
(André Malraux)
Today, April 23, it is no longer legal reasons...

1468
01:58:02,042 --> 01:58:06,602
those who will determine the results of 10000 votes.

1469
01:58:07,282 --> 01:58:10,042
As in many other circumstances,

1470
01:58:10,522 --> 01:58:14,642
'Yes' is a vote of trust in De Gaulle...

1471
01:58:15,562 --> 01:58:19,281
and 'No' the expression of the wish that he leaves.

1472
01:58:19,881 --> 01:58:22,921
(Giscard D'Estaing)
In response to the only question asked...

1473
01:58:23,481 --> 01:58:27,401
and which seeks my approval for the entire law,

1474
01:58:28,321 --> 01:58:33,321
as far as I'm concerned, unfortunately, but certainly,

1475
01:58:34,281 --> 01:58:35,360
I'll vote no.

1476
01:58:35,914 --> 01:58:45,563
We must try to understand why this progressive substitution of De Gaulle for a liberal bourgeois party.

1477
01:58:46,889 --> 01:58:48,659
I think it can be explained in two ways:...

1478
01:58:49,687 --> 01:58:54,828
One of the reasons that justified De Gaulle's rise to power,

1479
01:58:55,269 --> 01:59:00,340
the institutional disorder, the political impotence in the War in Algeria,

1480
01:59:01,174 --> 01:59:06,386
and the big obstacles to economical modernisation in France.

1481
01:59:06,919 --> 01:59:10,620
One can argue that those problems are largely solved.

1482
01:59:10,874 --> 01:59:16,267
That De Gaulle, a restorer, has remodelled the system and that we no longer need him.

1483
01:59:16,992 --> 01:59:23,491
On the other hand, economically, it's been a time when France has developed itself in a technocratic way,

1484
01:59:24,058 --> 01:59:32,028
with a leading role of the State without an apparatus of incorporation of the French economy,

1485
01:59:32,529 --> 01:59:35,347
as it is, to the Common Market and a larger Atlantic space,

1486
01:59:36,645 --> 01:59:42,590
essential for the large business that want the power to develop a multinational base...

1487
01:59:43,235 --> 01:59:45,838
and which are 'sinners' according to the Gaullist conception.

1488
01:59:46,036 --> 01:59:48,316
I think the majority answer will be 'no'.

1489
01:59:51,676 --> 01:59:53,316
Judging by what people say...

1490
01:59:54,996 --> 01:59:57,235
People are tired of his way...

1491
01:59:57,236 --> 02:00:01,114
of acting. "If the 'yes' doesn't win I'll leave".

1492
02:00:01,115 --> 02:00:02,394
Well, leave then!

1493
02:00:02,395 --> 02:00:04,955
Life will go on without him.

1494
02:00:05,915 --> 02:00:08,715
Anyway, he could die tomorrow morning...

1495
02:00:09,355 --> 02:00:11,315
and we'd have to replace him.
We are only human.

1496
02:00:11,835 --> 02:00:14,715
My husband nearly died a while ago,

1497
02:00:15,355 --> 02:00:19,434
I wasn't thinking of dying with him or committing suicide.

1498
02:00:20,754 --> 02:00:22,074
We have to go on living.

1499
02:00:24,454 --> 02:00:27,213
(April 1969, RTL, Paris)
Mr. Miterrand, I'd like to ask you this: Until the end of...

1500
02:00:27,214 --> 02:00:28,934
the May crisis your public image was that of...

1501
02:00:29,294 --> 02:00:31,614
the man who would put an end to the Gaullist regime.

1502
02:00:32,014 --> 02:00:36,493
How would present yourself before public opinion now?

1503
02:00:36,813 --> 02:00:40,493
What is your position before the referendum campaign?

1504
02:00:41,193 --> 02:00:45,992
(François Miterrand)
Allow me to underline firstly that I'm here...

1505
02:00:45,993 --> 02:00:48,353
as a guest of Radio Luxemburg.

1506
02:00:48,753 --> 02:00:50,272
But I'll answer your question.

1507
02:00:50,273 --> 02:00:54,272
You haven't put in the same wording as Broussine.

1508
02:00:55,152 --> 02:00:58,832
All that you were asked was if you are candidate to the presidency of the Republic.

1509
02:00:59,112 --> 02:01:00,392
Aren't you hurrying a bit?

1510
02:01:01,232 --> 02:01:04,632
Do you think a goverment of a united left is possible?

1511
02:01:07,792 --> 02:01:11,911
It should be possible, if everybody has the will.

1512
02:01:12,751 --> 02:01:15,390
Please, gentleman. Mr. Miterrand has the word to conclude.

1513
02:01:15,391 --> 02:01:17,191
It's getting late.

1514
02:01:17,391 --> 02:01:19,990
I must ask you not to interrupt.

1515
02:01:19,991 --> 02:01:24,870
I have already said, recently and publicly,

1516
02:01:24,871 --> 02:01:28,470
so this is no improvised answer,

1517
02:01:29,430 --> 02:01:33,030
that it seems absurd to me to think
that in our French country,

1518
02:01:33,430 --> 02:01:35,389
where we can have a French model of socialism,

1519
02:01:35,390 --> 02:01:38,749
to push for collective appropriation...

1520
02:01:38,750 --> 02:01:40,670
of the means of production and exchange.

1521
02:01:41,270 --> 02:01:44,030
Or to reduce French agriculture to the
category of 'kolkhozes',

1522
02:01:44,830 --> 02:01:47,388
Or that we think of nationalising and
collectivising...

1523
02:01:47,389 --> 02:01:50,549
the whole of French enterprises.

1524
02:01:50,789 --> 02:01:52,069
I've always said that we must...

1525
02:01:52,789 --> 02:01:55,229
combine our programme with the laws
of the market,

1526
02:01:55,789 --> 02:01:58,188
which means, in economical terms, to take into account the laws of profit.

1527
02:01:58,189 --> 02:02:01,748
Even with the best conscience, in the collective appropriation...

1528
02:02:01,749 --> 02:02:04,428
it's not possible to ignore the laws of profit.

1529
02:02:05,068 --> 02:02:06,587
So don't put words in my mouth which I haven't said.

1530
02:02:06,588 --> 02:02:09,947
After 50 years of socialist experiences...

1531
02:02:09,948 --> 02:02:12,787
we won't take the same path of mistakes...

1532
02:02:12,788 --> 02:02:16,428
that perhaps were indispensable or inevitable in the past.

1533
02:02:16,868 --> 02:02:19,128
We'll only take what is good from it.

1534
02:02:19,623 --> 02:02:25,492
Napoleon wrote: "I've made my plans with the dreams of my sleeping soldiers".

1535
02:02:26,676 --> 02:02:31,839
Often General De Gaulle made plans with the dreams of a sleeping France.

1536
02:02:32,935 --> 02:02:36,939
Because he found at his side, Frenchmen who didn't want to sleep.

1537
02:02:38,409 --> 02:02:42,927
Your yes so that he know he may count on you.

1538
02:02:44,485 --> 02:02:51,052
And also, to send a message to those who prepare something...

1539
02:02:51,567 --> 02:02:55,805
for the night of the referendum, thing that would be very grave.

1540
02:02:56,953 --> 02:03:04,779
And also, so that these adversaries know that if they want to recommence May,

1541
02:03:05,778 --> 02:03:09,519
we are ready to recommence the Champs Elysees March!

1542
02:03:31,663 --> 02:03:35,743
No: 53%.
Yes: 47%.

1543
02:03:36,583 --> 02:03:39,422
(Senate, April 27)
Little after midnight, General De Gaulle...

1544
02:03:39,423 --> 02:03:42,223
announces his departure in a
three line declaration.

1545
02:03:47,302 --> 02:03:50,020
Goodbye, goodbye De Gaulle!

1546
02:03:51,163 --> 02:03:55,442
And the next government? What has it got in store for us?

1547
02:03:55,534 --> 02:04:00,194
What now? There can be no Gaullists without De Gaulle.

1548
02:04:01,102 --> 02:04:03,621
We are constantly in this vicious circle.

1549
02:04:04,221 --> 02:04:06,821
We ask for small improvements in our lives.

1550
02:04:07,341 --> 02:04:08,861
But we give power to those who...

1551
02:04:09,701 --> 02:04:12,141
prevent us from living in a decent manner.

1552
02:04:13,261 --> 02:04:16,340
A man once told me: "Vote as red as you want,

1553
02:04:16,341 --> 02:04:17,381
it will pale down with time".

1554
02:04:18,421 --> 02:04:20,780
If we assume that the CP is the strongest party,

1555
02:04:21,700 --> 02:04:22,939
the best structured and organised,

1556
02:04:22,940 --> 02:04:24,860
the one the workers trust the most,

1557
02:04:27,660 --> 02:04:31,699
then, if it looks for an alliance to its right,

1558
02:04:31,700 --> 02:04:36,020
first the Socialist Party, then the middle-class, then, who knows?

1559
02:04:36,021 --> 02:04:39,936
There's no other path to real change but the path of unity.

1560
02:04:39,937 --> 02:04:43,373
I don't believe it possible to make a union of organisations of the left.

1561
02:04:43,791 --> 02:04:45,201
And, in fact, I think we must make a critique of this idea.

1562
02:04:46,276 --> 02:04:52,323
Which is, how many of these organisation really want a change in the regime?

1563
02:04:55,816 --> 02:05:00,814
I agree with you and what you are saying, but I don't believe in Guy Mollet.

1564
02:05:02,898 --> 02:05:04,498
There are people who still remember...

1565
02:05:05,898 --> 02:05:07,538
Anyhow, I remember...

1566
02:05:08,898 --> 02:05:12,178
Two years in Algeria with Guy Mollet count for something.

1567
02:05:12,458 --> 02:05:13,457
For me it's over!

1568
02:05:14,217 --> 02:05:15,217
So I told him:

1569
02:05:16,537 --> 02:05:19,417
The problem is not Guy Mollet.

1570
02:05:21,017 --> 02:05:25,137
The problem is winning the common struggle...

1571
02:05:26,817 --> 02:05:29,216
of communist and socialist workers,

1572
02:05:29,217 --> 02:05:30,376
and that of all democrats.

1573
02:05:31,056 --> 02:05:36,055
And I told him: "If you know an easier way, propose it to me, I'm simple man,

1574
02:05:36,056 --> 02:05:39,816
I'm willing to follow it".
But there is no other way.

1575
02:05:40,416 --> 02:05:42,816
(Party of L'Humanité, 1972)
Buy the T-shirts of Popular Unity!

1576
02:05:45,816 --> 02:05:47,854
Contribute to the triumph of Popular Unity!

1577
02:05:47,855 --> 02:05:50,655
Buy the common programme!

1578
02:06:02,735 --> 02:06:07,494
The programme of the Communist and Socialist parties and of the Left Radicals...

1579
02:06:32,173 --> 02:06:36,173
Our objective is the transformation of society.

1580
02:06:36,773 --> 02:06:40,971
It is indispensable that we have a majority of the people on our side...

1581
02:06:40,972 --> 02:06:44,292
in our democratic and revolutionary struggle.

1582
02:06:44,612 --> 02:06:45,852
The question of democracy...

1583
02:06:46,812 --> 02:06:51,092
is fundamental for the development of socialism.

1584
02:06:52,252 --> 02:06:55,171
I've explained in "History of the Stalinist phenomenon"...

1585
02:06:55,172 --> 02:06:59,531
that Lenin himself underestimated the importance of democracy.

1586
02:07:00,451 --> 02:07:02,811
Do you renounce the concept of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat?

1587
02:07:03,851 --> 02:07:07,771
Let's say not to the concept, for its mainly theoretical.

1588
02:07:08,451 --> 02:07:11,690
It hasn't a, let's say, operative value.

1589
02:07:11,691 --> 02:07:13,850
Would Lenin agree?

1590
02:07:13,851 --> 02:07:17,730
Maybe Lenin yes, but Marx surely wouldn't.

1591
02:07:18,170 --> 02:07:22,930
For Marx it was a concept opposed to the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie.

1592
02:07:23,530 --> 02:07:25,969
For Lenin it was different because precisely he...

1593
02:07:25,970 --> 02:07:29,169
led a Party that had taken power...

1594
02:07:29,170 --> 02:07:33,369
through a violent revolution, and had kept it by force.

1595
02:07:34,249 --> 02:07:39,248
So he had assimilated the theoretical concept of Dictatorship of the Proletariat...

1596
02:07:39,249 --> 02:07:43,169
together with the practical concept of directing a State in a dictatorial manner.

1597
02:07:44,049 --> 02:07:46,289
Because of this, in the Soviet Constitution of 1918,

1598
02:07:46,889 --> 02:07:50,248
the voice of one worker was worth 25,000 peasant voices.

1599
02:07:50,608 --> 02:07:52,208
That's why other parties were forbidden,

1600
02:07:53,008 --> 02:07:57,528
that's why there was no freedom of press, nor assembly, nor information, etc.

1601
02:07:59,368 --> 02:08:03,528
So there was a theoretical slide that was harmful...

1602
02:08:04,648 --> 02:08:07,166
because it hindered the democratic development...

1603
02:08:07,167 --> 02:08:09,087
that socialism needed in countries such as ours.

1604
02:08:09,687 --> 02:08:13,407
(In 1979, Eillenstein would be 'self-expelled' from the Party)

1605
02:08:14,007 --> 02:08:16,406
What counts and what is essential...

1606
02:08:16,407 --> 02:08:20,886
(United Left rally for the presidential election, La Courneuve, 1974)

1607
02:08:20,887 --> 02:08:25,166
is our concept of freedom and our capability of accepting difference without sectarianism.

1608
02:08:25,926 --> 02:08:30,166
Encouraged only by the need of liberating man from exploitation.

1609
02:08:32,726 --> 02:08:35,125
The Communist Party has moved..

1610
02:08:35,126 --> 02:08:38,085
from orthodoxy to the monopoly of heterodoxy.

1611
02:08:38,086 --> 02:08:41,564
In a way that the only good critique of Stalinism...

1612
02:08:41,565 --> 02:08:43,405
comes from inside the Communist Party itself.

1613
02:08:44,845 --> 02:08:48,364
It's inevitable that we clash, though not in the sense of fighting.

1614
02:08:48,365 --> 02:08:51,204
We find other works...

1615
02:08:51,205 --> 02:08:57,045
Debate is inevitable given that
we work in the same terrain...

1616
02:08:57,725 --> 02:09:01,083
and we part from similar set of principles.

1617
02:09:01,084 --> 02:09:03,044
Nothing can put obstacles to these confrontations...

1618
02:09:03,564 --> 02:09:06,564
becoming more profound and rich...

1619
02:09:07,204 --> 02:09:09,844
Another question is that of the political line.

1620
02:09:10,284 --> 02:09:14,444
I think the confusion arises, caused specially by the communists.

1621
02:09:15,163 --> 02:09:16,883
Some of them still don't get things right.

1622
02:09:17,403 --> 02:09:22,802
There's confusion outside and, sometimes, inside the CP...

1623
02:09:22,803 --> 02:09:25,042
insofar as political line is concerned...

1624
02:09:25,043 --> 02:09:27,282
and in the areas of debate...

1625
02:09:27,283 --> 02:09:31,123
and Marxist discussion and investigation.

1626
02:09:31,803 --> 02:09:33,962
I believe they have to take place in two different levels.

1627
02:09:34,962 --> 02:09:37,721
Sometimes it happened that these differences were felt quite rudely,

1628
02:09:37,722 --> 02:09:39,082
outside of the factories.

1629
02:09:40,556 --> 02:09:43,573
For us there is no way of fighting other than the workers' front.

1630
02:09:44,692 --> 02:09:46,709
Unity over internal divergences.

1631
02:09:47,433 --> 02:09:51,429
Unity of all workers and their organizations, to achieve our demands.

1632
02:09:52,033 --> 02:09:54,028
To overthrow the bourgeois and police State.

1633
02:09:54,241 --> 02:09:58,481
They are protected by the police, comrades.
Don't fall in their traps.

1634
02:10:01,361 --> 02:10:05,841
We've seen many times how this happened outside of the company's doors.

1635
02:10:06,881 --> 02:10:10,520
We deplore it, but we must speak clearly to show...

1636
02:10:11,040 --> 02:10:13,559
that we won't put down our flag before Stalinism...

1637
02:10:13,560 --> 02:10:16,919
We'll defend our political line...

1638
02:10:16,920 --> 02:10:20,200
and the workers' victories.

1639
02:10:26,599 --> 02:10:29,358
We defend the victories of the Bolshevik revolution of 1917...

1640
02:10:29,359 --> 02:10:31,039
that Stalinism and the bureaucracy are wasting.

1641
02:10:32,639 --> 02:10:35,559
Down with fascism!

1642
02:10:38,439 --> 02:10:40,079
Fascism shall fail!

1643
02:10:50,238 --> 02:10:54,758
Workers' democracy!

1644
02:11:14,234 --> 02:11:15,825
Stop the provocation!

1645
02:12:17,233 --> 02:12:21,513
(Prague, January 25, 1969. Funeral of Jan Palach)

1646
02:12:58,871 --> 02:13:01,870
I don't think it was a suicide, because a suicide means...

1647
02:13:02,390 --> 02:13:06,029
It's a solution for an individual...

1648
02:13:06,030 --> 02:13:09,070
I don't see any way out so I kill myself.

1649
02:13:09,390 --> 02:13:12,030
But that he had killed himself is completely different...

1650
02:13:13,670 --> 02:13:16,310
because he did it for everybody, not for himself.

1651
02:13:17,270 --> 02:13:22,029
He's shown a courage that none of us have.

1652
02:13:23,669 --> 02:13:25,748
He's done something truly extraordinary...

1653
02:13:25,749 --> 02:13:31,229
because he has made us feel guilty... For nor acting before.

1654
02:13:32,149 --> 02:13:35,388
We could have negotiated with someone, or...

1655
02:13:37,948 --> 02:13:42,388
I think this whole cortège expresses guilt.

1656
02:13:46,389 --> 02:13:50,189
FROM CHILE TO:
WHAT? THAT'S IT?

1657
02:14:01,350 --> 02:14:10,154
One day, we were successful; A Super-8 camera got inside the Lecumberrí jail, Mexico.

1658
02:14:23,315 --> 02:14:26,758
The next occasion was the magnetic tape with the voice of Solzhenitsyn

1659
02:14:27,434 --> 02:14:28,924
I'll water...

1660
02:14:30,571 --> 02:14:32,402
I'll woods...

1661
02:14:33,240 --> 02:14:36,471
A cruel prince, with slanted eyes,

1662
02:14:36,677 --> 02:14:38,269
has stolen this lake...

1663
02:14:39,379 --> 02:14:40,573
The footprints.

1664
02:14:40,781 --> 02:14:42,578
Someone has lit a fire.

1665
02:14:43,283 --> 02:14:45,045
The fire has gone out.

1666
02:14:45,251 --> 02:14:46,377
The man is gone.

1667
02:14:48,654 --> 02:14:50,417
The lake is desert,

1668
02:14:52,391 --> 02:14:54,450
beloved lake,

1669
02:14:56,762 --> 02:14:58,093
motherland.

1670
02:14:58,784 --> 02:15:03,303
Greetings to all French audience from Persepolis.

1671
02:15:04,143 --> 02:15:09,382
(Persepolis, 1979. Commemoration of the 25.000th anniversary of the Persian kingdom)

1672
02:15:09,383 --> 02:15:12,462
The first image showed the Shah of Persia and the Shahbanou,

1673
02:15:12,463 --> 02:15:17,382
welcoming the illustrious and august guests of all lands:

1674
02:15:17,383 --> 02:15:18,982
Kings, princes, heads of state...

1675
02:15:19,622 --> 02:15:23,902
Are united in Persepolis, the Versailles of yore.

1676
02:15:24,822 --> 02:15:26,022
What an image!

1677
02:15:26,502 --> 02:15:31,462
The Shahbanou of Iran with Mr. Podgorny,
president of the USSR:

1678
02:15:31,782 --> 02:15:34,742
There's Marshall Tito and Lady Tito...

1679
02:15:37,221 --> 02:15:41,261
and many heads of state that represent almost
every nation in the world.

1680
02:15:43,501 --> 02:15:46,420
I don't think I have ever seen so many crowned heads...

1681
02:15:46,421 --> 02:15:49,461
and some many heads of state together.

1682
02:15:50,541 --> 02:15:54,539
Meanwhile two heralds...

1683
02:15:54,540 --> 02:15:58,980
come to announce the beginning of the ceremony.

1684
02:16:00,500 --> 02:16:04,660
The heralds come to inform his Imperial Majesty,

1685
02:16:05,020 --> 02:16:09,260
the Shah-in-shah Arya Mehr, which means,
"King of kings, light of the aryans",

1686
02:16:10,140 --> 02:16:11,939
that the feasts are ready.

1687
02:16:12,657 --> 02:16:14,298
"King of kings, light of the Aryans."

1688
02:16:15,468 --> 02:16:20,228
Thus also begin the loyalty declarations that Iranian police...

1689
02:16:20,624 --> 02:16:25,094
make the families of condemned men sign, in exchange for the mercy of the sovereign,

1690
02:16:25,940 --> 02:16:28,135
whom we see here protected by his bullet-proof vest.

1691
02:16:29,903 --> 02:16:31,840
combed by a French hairdresser...

1692
02:16:31,658 --> 02:16:34,578
(Wanted: Ulrike Meinhoff, from the Baader group)

1693
02:16:33,257 --> 02:16:37,326
and every important lady who takes part in the ceremony...

1694
02:16:37,709 --> 02:16:42,533
has had her hair done by a famous parisian hairdresser, and they make up done...

1695
02:16:41,498 --> 02:16:43,617
(Larry Bensky)

1696
02:16:43,618 --> 02:16:47,216
If you engage in revolutionary activity in any country...

1697
02:16:47,217 --> 02:16:49,257
you risk no only repression but death.

1698
02:16:50,217 --> 02:16:51,736
If you are thinking about becoming a revolutionary...

1699
02:16:51,737 --> 02:16:56,336
you should know, though it may not be a happy thought,

1700
02:16:56,337 --> 02:16:59,857
that any day you can find yourself...

1701
02:17:35,856 --> 02:17:39,855
(Arrest of Margrit Schiller)

1702
02:17:47,774 --> 02:17:50,454
Ulrike.
Tania.

1703
02:17:52,854 --> 02:17:54,014
Sarita.

1704
02:17:59,913 --> 02:18:00,993
Nguyen Van Troi.

1705
02:18:02,073 --> 02:18:03,193
Javier Héraud.

1706
02:18:09,073 --> 02:18:10,112
Malcolm X.

1707
02:18:10,113 --> 02:18:11,313
Camilo Torres.

1708
02:18:11,453 --> 02:18:12,852
Txiki.

1709
02:18:23,272 --> 02:18:24,312
Víctor Jara.

1710
02:18:37,191 --> 02:18:38,431
Julian Grimau.

1711
02:18:38,951 --> 02:18:40,151
George Jackson.

1712
02:18:53,510 --> 02:18:54,670
Carlos Marighella.

1713
02:19:07,189 --> 02:19:08,269
Roque Dalton.

1714
02:19:08,689 --> 02:19:09,889
Pierre Overnay.

1715
02:19:47,635 --> 02:19:51,180
Pierre Overnay was killed without being, by any instance, a threat to the officer in charge,

1716
02:19:51,976 --> 02:19:56,284
whom, apparently, shot him without having been attacked. Paralel to the investigation,

1717
02:19:56,860 --> 02:19:59,663
has naturally aroused many comments; For the CGT it was a provocation,

1718
02:19:59,951 --> 02:20:07,226
such acts are made to deviate the workers from their true demands.

1719
02:20:07,776 --> 02:20:08,810
Let's see.

1720
02:20:09,597 --> 02:20:12,351
An action never judged by its support among the workers...

1721
02:20:13,247 --> 02:20:14,725
receives tags from whoever wants to put them.

1722
02:20:15,419 --> 02:20:16,897
For the left of the regime: Provocation.

1723
02:20:18,839 --> 02:20:20,176
For the CFDT: An adventure.

1724
02:20:21,002 --> 02:20:22,490
For the CGT: Capitulation.

1725
02:20:23,290 --> 02:20:26,641
There was a whole repertoire of stupid words: 'Lefty', 'revisio',

1726
02:20:27,074 --> 02:20:29,446
so as not to look for the complexity of the conflict in a sort of...

1727
02:20:29,899 --> 02:20:33,036
binary system, where each defined himself not by the class struggle,

1728
02:20:33,530 --> 02:20:34,857
but by the struggle between the organisations.

1729
02:20:35,353 --> 02:20:36,258
It is that from the moment you give...

1730
02:20:36,610 --> 02:20:38,685
an organization the monopoly of the representation of the class,

1731
02:20:39,100 --> 02:20:40,548
it evidently no longer matters.

1732
02:20:41,682 --> 02:20:44,582
As though we had to wait until the day we had our backs against the walls...

1733
02:20:45,006 --> 02:20:48,687
of a stadium surrounded by the military to realise that we had something to talk about.

1734
02:20:49,684 --> 02:20:51,797
As though the frontiers of the organizations and the grupuscules,

1735
02:20:52,804 --> 02:20:55,171
separated foreign towns instinctively hostile.

1736
02:20:56,580 --> 02:20:59,812
So we played at opposing each other; Grand against Joint Français, LIP against Rateau.

1737
02:21:00,454 --> 02:21:02,737
You send us against the cops, put us out in the street,

1738
02:21:03,424 --> 02:21:06,209
and now you want to negotiate? You're ridiculous!

1739
02:21:06,920 --> 02:21:08,067
It wasn't so clear at the bases.

1740
02:21:08,905 --> 02:21:11,710
Well, the negotiations are broken up, the strike fund is zeroed,

1741
02:21:12,037 --> 02:21:14,593
what do we do? Can we produce?

1742
02:21:16,537 --> 02:21:20,332
Produce what?
Doesn't matter what.

1743
02:21:23,241 --> 02:21:27,188
I don't know, you could give your opinion, if you think we have done...

1744
02:21:28,094 --> 02:21:32,001
enough for two months' strike or not.

1745
02:21:32,413 --> 02:21:33,400
I'd like to know what you think.

1746
02:21:36,122 --> 02:21:38,637
Anyway, we have a wonderful oportunity of showing ourselves,

1747
02:21:39,642 --> 02:21:41,130
at next week's demo.

1748
02:21:42,561 --> 02:21:47,567
If we put 500 or 600 men on the street...

1749
02:21:48,320 --> 02:21:50,252
It's us who have to fight so that the comrades come!

1750
02:21:51,028 --> 02:21:54,387
They won't just come. But why do they come to get their pay...

1751
02:21:54,719 --> 02:21:57,789
at the end of the month and don't defend their interests?
Because we don't fight enough with ideas.

1752
02:21:59,223 --> 02:22:00,162
It's a sad thing, but it's true.

1753
02:22:01,016 --> 02:22:02,637
If we struggled a bit more to win over these comrades,

1754
02:22:03,302 --> 02:22:05,315
then perhaps we will not be a hundred fools having fun made out of.

1755
02:22:05,857 --> 02:22:08,565
Maybe we can get 500 steelworkers working, that's how it is.

1756
02:22:09,403 --> 02:22:11,670
That's why the commissions don't work as planned.

1757
02:22:12,352 --> 02:22:14,067
There are only a handful who work, that's the problem.

1758
02:22:15,977 --> 02:22:17,328
We've talked to them, we've been calling them for months.

1759
02:22:18,545 --> 02:22:19,681
We've been sucking up to them for months.

1760
02:22:20,216 --> 02:22:21,968
We've been asking them to give us a hand for months,

1761
02:22:22,361 --> 02:22:24,355
They aren't coming. And you are not going to get a rifle to shoot them, leave it...

1762
02:22:26,591 --> 02:22:28,381
But we must convince ourselves.

1763
02:22:29,227 --> 02:22:32,218
We can win the battle, we can have a left-wing government,

1764
02:22:32,631 --> 02:22:36,134
but we must convince ourselves, and to do it...

1765
02:22:36,769 --> 02:22:37,975
we have to convince the others.

1766
02:22:38,795 --> 02:22:40,748
Because, for fuck's sake, we are in a new situation,

1767
02:22:41,601 --> 02:22:43,828
a situation created out of Pompidou's death.

1768
02:22:48,881 --> 02:22:51,670
On April 6, 1974 Georges Pompidou dies.

1769
02:22:52,787 --> 02:22:54,510
It is then that Jacques Chirac has the idea...

1770
02:22:54,774 --> 02:22:56,334
that in order to make the gaullism of the future triumph,

1771
02:22:57,005 --> 02:22:59,462
the best way was to get Giscard D'Estaing elected at once.

1772
02:23:00,369 --> 02:23:05,394
And for the papacies, two chapels, to the left and to the right.

1773
02:23:07,982 --> 02:23:12,724
Advance without precipitation, towards meditation.

1774
02:23:16,295 --> 02:23:19,695
Nixon looks uncomfortable in the stairways of Nôtre-Dame, tribulated.

1775
02:23:20,415 --> 02:23:23,375
In fact, this entire collection of heads of state looks ill.

1776
02:23:27,394 --> 02:23:29,514
Power must be bad for your health. Just look at them.

1777
02:23:30,514 --> 02:23:34,774
Compare their expressions with the clear look of a cat. It's the definitive proof.

1778
02:23:36,254 --> 02:23:38,014
A cat is never on the side of power.

1779
02:23:38,634 --> 02:23:41,392
To prove it, consider the ceremony that the good...

1780
02:23:41,393 --> 02:23:44,553
king Baldwin of Belgium held every year in Ypres.

1781
02:23:45,053 --> 02:23:48,493
In the Middle-Ages, the people of Ypres was accused of adoring cats.

1782
02:24:53,657 --> 02:24:56,285
He's gone mad.

1783
02:24:56,660 --> 02:24:59,288
I can't do nothing but...

1784
02:24:59,663 --> 02:25:02,530
look at him growl and struggle.

1785
02:25:03,300 --> 02:25:05,097
He bangs against everything.

1786
02:25:05,903 --> 02:25:08,132
He didn't want to let me...

1787
02:25:08,404 --> 02:25:10,998
change his dressings.

1788
02:25:25,947 --> 02:25:29,027
Until a while ago, those who held the power oppressed and killed directly.

1789
02:25:30,547 --> 02:25:34,187
Today, death and madness can be a simple by-product of their activities.

1790
02:25:36,067 --> 02:25:40,907
In Japan, the Chisso company has poisoned the water of Minamata with mercury residues.

1791
02:25:41,987 --> 02:25:45,666
The fishermen and their families suffer from what they call simply, 'the illness'.

1792
02:25:46,946 --> 02:25:48,226
Deformed babies are born.

1793
02:26:06,059 --> 02:26:08,527
(Osaka, November 28, 1970)

1794
02:26:09,145 --> 02:26:12,105
(Chisso shareholders meeting)

1795
02:26:18,637 --> 02:26:20,127
Let the victims speak!

1796
02:26:20,873 --> 02:26:22,966
Let them speak!

1797
02:26:29,915 --> 02:26:31,610
Let your rage burst!

1798
02:26:32,885 --> 02:26:34,408
Resuscitate the dead!

1799
02:27:39,948 --> 02:27:42,644
CHANT OF THE VICTIMS OF MINAMATA

1800
02:27:56,830 --> 02:28:00,027
(The President of Chisso)

1801
02:28:23,488 --> 02:28:26,150
You are a parent, too.

1802
02:28:26,591 --> 02:28:31,221
Do you understand what I'm saying?

1803
02:28:31,529 --> 02:28:34,362
We are both parents.

1804
02:28:35,000 --> 02:28:38,059
Can you understand that?

1805
02:28:39,303 --> 02:28:42,067
Can you imagine what I'm feeling?

1806
02:28:42,373 --> 02:28:45,365
Stop smiling!

1807
02:28:46,310 --> 02:28:47,868
Parents have...

1808
02:28:48,245 --> 02:28:49,075
their children,

1809
02:28:49,346 --> 02:28:52,110
And the children have their parents,

1810
02:28:52,383 --> 02:28:54,282
Can you understand that?

1811
02:28:54,984 --> 02:28:57,179
To us, old people, without children,

1812
02:28:57,487 --> 02:28:59,512
everything is over!

1813
02:29:11,274 --> 02:29:15,353
(Watergate trials, 1973)

1814
02:29:15,354 --> 02:29:17,873
When it is the highest authority of the world's greatest power

1815
02:29:17,874 --> 02:29:19,114
sitting in the bench...

1816
02:29:19,794 --> 02:29:21,434
things are quite different.

1817
02:30:26,390 --> 02:30:28,869
Not a single demonstration in all of the United States.

1818
02:30:28,870 --> 02:30:30,670
Not a single popular intervention,

1819
02:30:30,710 --> 02:30:32,150
spontaneous or organised.

1820
02:30:33,524 --> 02:30:35,590
The most gigantic crack in the Power...

1821
02:30:35,624 --> 02:30:39,589
permanently contested during the '60s wasn't exploited by anyone.

1822
02:30:40,029 --> 02:30:44,308
(Larry Bensky)
The same people that had united to...

1823
02:30:44,309 --> 02:30:47,149
protest against the war in Vietnam...

1824
02:30:48,269 --> 02:30:51,749
now say we have to do something different at the same time.

1825
02:30:52,509 --> 02:30:55,868
Sometimes you have to look inside yourself.

1826
02:30:57,148 --> 02:31:00,788
You have to feel good vibrations, live in harmony with others...

1827
02:31:01,468 --> 02:31:03,548
to be at peace with the world,

1828
02:31:04,228 --> 02:31:10,068
I mean, with the environment, with the interpersonal world.

1829
02:31:13,707 --> 02:31:17,387
In the terrain of current affairs, maybe there aren't any demonstrations in the streets.

1830
02:31:18,227 --> 02:31:23,307
You no longer see political gestures like raising your fist all the time.

1831
02:31:23,987 --> 02:31:25,066
But the struggle continues...

1832
02:31:25,067 --> 02:31:29,626
and I believe people participate even more, each his own way.

1833
02:31:31,586 --> 02:31:33,945
They know how to work together.

1834
02:31:33,946 --> 02:31:40,105
And that doesn't mean great assemblies from dawn to dusk...

1835
02:31:40,106 --> 02:31:44,266
talking about Marx, Lenin, Mao without actually doing anything.

1836
02:31:44,906 --> 02:31:48,704
Now they know how to work together better than before.

1837
02:31:48,705 --> 02:31:51,584
It's something. Before it was terrible.

1838
02:31:51,585 --> 02:31:55,584
The famous and referenced movement of the '60s...

1839
02:31:55,585 --> 02:31:58,345
could have done something.

1840
02:31:59,385 --> 02:32:03,743
But it didn't have any knowledge of work methods...

1841
02:32:03,744 --> 02:32:07,864
which, for me, would have allowed for a much more effective work.

1842
02:32:08,984 --> 02:32:12,424
(October 1967. The Pentagon)

1843
02:32:18,424 --> 02:32:22,023
(Admiral Mohr)

1844
02:32:31,143 --> 02:32:32,823
Looking at these images, in retrospective,

1845
02:32:33,423 --> 02:32:36,422
You can identify the tricks the authorities played on us.

1846
02:32:36,423 --> 02:32:40,742
In practice, no unarmed demonstrator could pass the lines of the soldiers.

1847
02:32:41,222 --> 02:32:43,622
In front of us were the buildings of the Pentagon,

1848
02:32:44,062 --> 02:32:48,342
objectives of the 'direct action' to which the organisers called.

1849
02:32:48,822 --> 02:32:51,861
Then, when it was about to start,

1850
02:32:51,862 --> 02:32:55,580
surprise, surprise. No soldiers, no bayonets.

1851
02:32:55,581 --> 02:32:58,980
No steely looks. Just a few policemen...

1852
02:32:58,981 --> 02:33:02,701
that are pushed aside by some demonstrators that shout joyfully...

1853
02:33:03,381 --> 02:33:06,541
when they trespass a frontier no-one seemed willing to defend.

1854
02:33:36,739 --> 02:33:38,818
And everything stops here, at the stairs...

1855
02:33:38,819 --> 02:33:41,499
after a symbolic attempt of getting inside.

1856
02:33:41,799 --> 02:33:43,279
The police were clearly scared.

1857
02:33:45,219 --> 02:33:46,339
I filmed it...

1858
02:33:46,739 --> 02:33:49,258
and I showed it as a victory for the movement.

1859
02:33:49,918 --> 02:33:51,997
But, when I look back at these scenes again,

1860
02:33:51,998 --> 02:33:54,518
and I unite them with the stories the police told us...

1861
02:33:54,658 --> 02:33:58,378
about how it was they who lived the fire of the police stations in their 1968,

1862
02:33:59,418 --> 02:34:03,177
I ask myself: weren't some of our victories in the '60s...

1863
02:34:03,178 --> 02:34:04,577
made out of the same stuff?

1864
02:34:05,817 --> 02:34:08,376
By then all we knew was that it was only a way of beginning...

1865
02:34:08,377 --> 02:34:13,577
and, if we had in any moment the sensation of...

1866
02:34:14,457 --> 02:34:18,017
euphoria of the revolution that began,

1867
02:34:22,496 --> 02:34:26,896
it was false, it was tragic, but it was a great moment.

1868
02:34:27,656 --> 02:34:31,536
They say '68/'69 in the United States were like '05 in Russia.

1869
02:34:32,216 --> 02:34:35,056
That's good, because we still have 12 years to know if they were right.

1870
02:34:37,307 --> 02:34:40,764
The situation of the guerrilla today,

1871
02:34:42,845 --> 02:34:48,215
can be defined as of some recovery...

1872
02:34:48,484 --> 02:34:53,353
in comparison to the long and hard process...

1873
02:34:53,622 --> 02:34:56,385
of crisis, of hardships...

1874
02:34:56,658 --> 02:34:59,058
that it went through in these last years.

1875
02:34:59,059 --> 02:35:02,774
In 1970, after 8 years, Douglas Bravo is still giving interviews in the mountains.

1876
02:35:03,254 --> 02:35:04,653
He has no support.

1877
02:35:04,654 --> 02:35:07,174
Cuban or otherwise.

1878
02:35:07,202 --> 02:35:09,232
We could say that this crisis...

1879
02:35:10,372 --> 02:35:13,738
has its origins mainly in that...

1880
02:35:14,008 --> 02:35:17,842
in the first years of the struggle...

1881
02:35:21,949 --> 02:35:25,942
the movement used a tactic,

1882
02:35:26,220 --> 02:35:28,688
that we can call 'insurrectionalist'.

1883
02:35:28,989 --> 02:35:33,186
We wanted to make the revolution in Venezuela...

1884
02:35:33,760 --> 02:35:35,625
in the manner...

1885
02:35:36,462 --> 02:35:38,430
of the Russian revolution;

1886
02:35:38,965 --> 02:35:45,497
Storming the major cities in a few days.

1887
02:35:47,440 --> 02:35:54,003
Later, the Venezuelan revolutionary movement committed another mistake,

1888
02:35:54,813 --> 02:35:58,579
we could say that less so...

1889
02:35:58,850 --> 02:36:00,681
than in others countries in Latin America,

1890
02:36:00,986 --> 02:36:02,613
but nonetheless committed it;

1891
02:36:02,888 --> 02:36:05,515
Which was to apply...

1892
02:36:05,823 --> 02:36:09,657
the concept of 'Foquism'...

1893
02:36:09,960 --> 02:36:16,890
exposed by the philosopher and journalist Régis Debray...

1894
02:36:17,168 --> 02:36:20,763
in his book: Revolution in the Revolution.

1895
02:36:20,850 --> 02:36:25,289
(1970. Régis Debray in his Bolivian jail)
There's no doubt the struggle is hard.

1896
02:36:26,289 --> 02:36:27,729
Do you think it will go on?
Of course!

1897
02:36:28,809 --> 02:36:31,729
Maybe in different forms,

1898
02:36:33,489 --> 02:36:36,929
but it will always be the same struggle, at least in Latin America.

1899
02:36:38,809 --> 02:36:42,008
Don't you think that the coming decade will be different from the previous one?

1900
02:36:42,328 --> 02:36:44,288
Of course, because it will be another decade.

1901
02:36:47,648 --> 02:36:49,208
But the revolutionary struggle will continue...

1902
02:36:50,688 --> 02:36:54,088
in the way that each country, each nation, defines it...

1903
02:36:55,568 --> 02:37:00,287
specifically according to their tradition and national reality.

1904
02:37:01,167 --> 02:37:04,886
They will be as dramatic and hard...

1905
02:37:04,887 --> 02:37:07,207
as the ones from the past.

1906
02:37:08,447 --> 02:37:11,647
My action has no particular character.

1907
02:37:12,127 --> 02:37:15,126
I'd like it if it were part of a more general action.

1908
02:37:16,446 --> 02:37:19,566
For the moment I'm inactive, so the question doesn't make any sense.

1909
02:37:20,366 --> 02:37:22,686
Freed during a democratic interlude in Bolivia,

1910
02:37:23,126 --> 02:37:25,525
Debray goes to Chile to observe a process...

1911
02:37:25,526 --> 02:37:29,366
that seems to be the antithesis of "Revolution in the revolution".

1912
02:37:30,166 --> 02:37:32,364
Thus his need to ask Salvador Allende...

1913
02:37:32,365 --> 02:37:33,565
about his relationship with the Cuban revolution.

1914
02:37:35,341 --> 02:37:38,469
I arrived in Cuba on January 20, 1959,

1915
02:37:38,844 --> 02:37:40,607
I arrived at a very curious moment.

1916
02:37:40,880 --> 02:37:44,475
That afternoon there was a parade that was led by...

1917
02:37:46,118 --> 02:37:49,518
two hundred policemen from Miami, and in an open car,

1918
02:37:49,821 --> 02:37:52,051
went the mayor of Miami...

1919
02:37:53,391 --> 02:37:56,158
and I think that the mayor of Havana was also there

1920
02:37:56,461 --> 02:38:01,454
So the next morning I was considering taking a plane back to Chile,

1921
02:38:02,033 --> 02:38:05,764
When I met Carlos Rafael Rodriguez.

1922
02:38:06,037 --> 02:38:08,630
He asked me, "What are you doing here?", I said "I came to see this revolution"...

1923
02:38:08,939 --> 02:38:10,600
but given that it doesn't really exist...

1924
02:38:10,874 --> 02:38:13,434
Then he said, "You're mistaken, Salvador"...

1925
02:38:13,710 --> 02:38:16,042
stay here, talk with the leaders".

1926
02:38:16,780 --> 02:38:21,174
And he got me in touch with Raul Castro...

1927
02:38:21,451 --> 02:38:26,255
and then, immediately, I went to see Fidel.

1928
02:38:29,192 --> 02:38:32,059
We were in a big hall, and there were guajiros...

1929
02:38:32,328 --> 02:38:36,389
playing checkers, guns everywhere...

1930
02:38:36,699 --> 02:38:38,428
I have a photo somewhere.

1931
02:38:38,734 --> 02:38:42,328
I was close to a chimney, which was the only clear place

1932
02:38:42,604 --> 02:38:47,041
and there were the two of us talking.

1933
02:38:47,442 --> 02:38:49,069
From the start I was impressed...

1934
02:38:49,377 --> 02:38:51,868
by his overflowing intelligence, this incredible...

1935
02:38:52,247 --> 02:38:55,774
overwhelming thing which is like a human waterfall.

1936
02:39:10,120 --> 02:39:12,479
Here, Fidel is revealing the secrets...

1937
02:39:12,480 --> 02:39:15,320
of Italian cuisine to the Italian editor Feltrinelli.

1938
02:39:15,329 --> 02:39:18,604
Bechamel sauce, with meat. 5 stacks

1939
02:39:18,871 --> 02:39:22,773
Half an hour in the oven at an adequate temperature.

1940
02:39:23,610 --> 02:39:27,068
Wait, I forgot; On top of the bechamel, cheese!

1941
02:39:29,159 --> 02:39:33,199
Fidel had the ability of great actors to transform the accidental in legendary.

1942
02:39:33,678 --> 02:39:36,398
This gesture, for example, of moving the microphones,

1943
02:39:36,878 --> 02:39:38,358
born out of the need of keeping his hands busy...

1944
02:39:38,378 --> 02:39:40,358
when he was still an inexperienced speaker.

1945
02:39:40,958 --> 02:39:46,518
It has become a ritual gesture, which Cubans anticipate delighted before his speeches.

1946
02:39:47,438 --> 02:39:50,258
Only once did he find microphones which couldn't be moved.

1947
02:39:50,358 --> 02:39:51,477
In Moscow.

1948
02:39:54,438 --> 02:39:56,030
Long live...

1949
02:39:57,141 --> 02:40:00,872
proletarian Internationalism!

1950
02:40:08,985 --> 02:40:10,452
Long live...

1951
02:40:11,888 --> 02:40:13,719
the friendship...

1952
02:40:13,990 --> 02:40:18,518
between the Soviet and Cuban peoples!

1953
02:40:29,805 --> 02:40:31,272
Long live...

1954
02:40:31,540 --> 02:40:33,872
the Soviet Union!

1955
02:40:38,647 --> 02:40:40,877
The time will come when the revolution,

1956
02:40:41,083 --> 02:40:43,846
which is today a dynamic process,

1957
02:40:44,018 --> 02:40:46,878
that destroys the old and builds the new...

1958
02:40:47,088 --> 02:40:49,488
will institutionalise itself!

1959
02:40:49,691 --> 02:40:51,625
Neither we are eternal...

1960
02:40:51,826 --> 02:40:55,193
nor is this time of Revolution eternal.

1961
02:40:55,396 --> 02:40:57,227
The day will come when...

1962
02:40:57,432 --> 02:41:00,662
this new order the revolution is creating...

1963
02:41:00,867 --> 02:41:05,065
will acquire an institutional character.

1964
02:41:05,272 --> 02:41:08,241
And this essential and real democracy...

1965
02:41:08,442 --> 02:41:11,138
will acquire new forms.

1966
02:41:26,726 --> 02:41:29,627
Meanwhile, we have elections here every month...

1967
02:41:29,929 --> 02:41:31,624
but at the public square.

1968
02:41:36,968 --> 02:41:39,903
Here we could ask...

1969
02:41:41,139 --> 02:41:43,437
is anyone against?

1970
02:41:48,079 --> 02:41:50,639
Does anyone abstain?

1971
02:41:52,549 --> 02:41:55,916
Then, the resolutions of the congress...

1972
02:41:56,186 --> 02:41:58,313
are approved by unanimity!

1973
02:42:08,190 --> 02:42:10,869
(1975, Year of the institutionalisation)

1974
02:42:10,969 --> 02:42:13,869
(I Congress of the Cuban Communist Party)

1975
02:42:19,629 --> 02:42:24,469
Among the speakers: Mikhail Suslov.

1976
02:42:27,468 --> 02:42:29,468
Janos Kadar.

1977
02:42:31,148 --> 02:42:33,508
General Giap.

1978
02:42:58,813 --> 02:43:01,713
Everything is resumed in the Party.

1979
02:43:02,816 --> 02:43:06,411
It synthesises the dreams of the revolutionaries...

1980
02:43:06,719 --> 02:43:09,119
of all our history.

1981
02:43:09,589 --> 02:43:12,353
It specifies the ideas, the principles...

1982
02:43:12,625 --> 02:43:14,991
and the strength of the Revolution.

1983
02:43:15,495 --> 02:43:18,486
It absorbs our individualisms...

1984
02:43:18,797 --> 02:43:22,494
and teaches us to think in terms of collectivity.

1985
02:43:22,801 --> 02:43:24,826
It is our educator,

1986
02:43:25,103 --> 02:43:27,663
our teacher, our guide,

1987
02:43:27,940 --> 02:43:30,101
our vigilant conscience.

1988
02:43:30,375 --> 02:43:32,866
When aren't ourselves able...

1989
02:43:33,145 --> 02:43:35,705
to see our mistakes, our faults...

1990
02:43:35,980 --> 02:43:37,709
and our limitations.

1991
02:43:38,049 --> 02:43:42,017
(Mújica, Venezuelan Communist Party)
The Cuban case won't be repeated!

1992
02:43:42,018 --> 02:43:44,820
Marx said it, History doesn't repeat itself...

1993
02:43:45,089 --> 02:43:47,421
and when it does...

1994
02:43:47,692 --> 02:43:50,024
it is as a farce!

1995
02:43:50,394 --> 02:43:55,194
(Volodia Teitelboim, Chilean Communist Party)
We believe that after the Cuban Revolution

1996
02:43:55,499 --> 02:43:58,332
North-American imperialism was put into alert...

1997
02:43:58,635 --> 02:44:01,399
and it has set up in our countries...

1998
02:44:01,671 --> 02:44:04,162
an anti-guerrilla apparatus...

1999
02:44:04,474 --> 02:44:06,772
that cannot be easily overcome.

2000
02:44:07,283 --> 02:44:09,363
(Wallender, The Pentagon)

2001
02:44:13,215 --> 02:44:15,945
That's why the Chilean way...

2002
02:44:16,218 --> 02:44:19,415
which is the way of an entire people...

2003
02:44:19,822 --> 02:44:22,347
willing to do the Revolution...

2004
02:44:22,558 --> 02:44:25,755
is much better protected...

2005
02:44:26,028 --> 02:44:28,154
against an imperialist attack...

2006
02:44:28,429 --> 02:44:32,490
and more effective, as far as results go,

2007
02:44:32,767 --> 02:44:36,897
than the heroics of a few young men...

2008
02:44:37,171 --> 02:44:40,629
in a mountain or in a city to overthrow a government.

2009
02:44:41,821 --> 02:44:47,339
The government of Popular Unity that will take place in Chile,

2010
02:44:47,340 --> 02:44:49,420
that should take place in Chile,

2011
02:44:50,420 --> 02:44:55,140
with the designation of Allende as President of the Republic,

2012
02:44:56,900 --> 02:44:59,740
is not necessarily a government of Marxist ideology.

2013
02:45:01,020 --> 02:45:02,819
It is a government of unity...

2014
02:45:03,499 --> 02:45:08,059
that will include communists, socialists and radicals.

2015
02:45:09,779 --> 02:45:11,459
In our view, we consider...

2016
02:45:11,959 --> 02:45:15,658
(Lille, 1970. Georges Marchais)

2017
02:45:15,659 --> 02:45:17,778
the Chilean experience...

2018
02:45:17,779 --> 02:45:22,458
confirms the thesis of the French Communist Party.

2019
02:45:24,418 --> 02:45:28,298
This thesis is that the union of the parties of the left...

2020
02:45:29,778 --> 02:45:34,578
with a clear programme, with a clear perspective,

2021
02:45:35,858 --> 02:45:42,257
will allow for the formation of a Popular Unity...

2022
02:45:43,057 --> 02:45:46,977
strong enough to defeat the bourgeoisie.

2023
02:45:48,817 --> 02:45:54,057
I must underline that, after the triumph of Salvador Allende,

2024
02:45:55,776 --> 02:45:58,536
a few democrats...

2025
02:45:59,736 --> 02:46:01,456
some Christian-democrats included,

2026
02:46:02,496 --> 02:46:04,776
(First image taken of Allende as President)

2027
02:46:06,296 --> 02:46:09,656
at first hesitant towards the Popular Unity,

2028
02:46:11,136 --> 02:46:13,055
now offer their support.

2029
02:46:14,055 --> 02:46:18,335
This is the plain confirmation of the thesis of the Communists.

2030
02:46:19,335 --> 02:46:23,735
The union of the parties and forces of the left...

2031
02:46:25,495 --> 02:46:30,413
is capable of setting off, in a given country,

2032
02:46:30,414 --> 02:46:33,294
and I think it is our case, too,

2033
02:46:34,014 --> 02:46:39,054
a majority movement capable of defeating the bourgeoisie.

2034
02:46:40,014 --> 02:46:43,294
We salute this Chilean experience.

2035
02:46:44,974 --> 02:46:46,773
And what's more, let me say this.

2036
02:46:47,493 --> 02:46:51,413
Given that this is a very dangerous experience for the capitalists...

2037
02:46:51,453 --> 02:46:55,092
there's risk of pressure, even intervention,

2038
02:46:55,093 --> 02:46:58,013
specially of American imperialism.

2039
02:46:59,053 --> 02:47:04,212
I'm sure that if such intervention ever took place in Chile,

2040
02:47:05,092 --> 02:47:08,732
The French Communist Party and, I'm sure, the rest of the parties of the left,

2041
02:47:09,012 --> 02:47:14,091
will know how to take initiatives that lead to the full support of the French democrats...

2042
02:47:14,092 --> 02:47:15,692
to our Chilean comrades.

2043
02:47:27,931 --> 02:47:34,331
(Santiago, 1972. Allende meets with workers from a nationalised factory)

2044
02:47:36,507 --> 02:47:38,406
The good things and the bad things!

2045
02:47:38,809 --> 02:47:43,337
And now it'll be the same. For there are some journalists here; And I'm glad for that.

2046
02:47:43,547 --> 02:47:45,947
Chileans and foreign...

2047
02:47:46,316 --> 02:47:48,147
Let them stay...

2048
02:47:48,518 --> 02:47:50,418
specially the foreign ones.

2049
02:47:50,687 --> 02:47:52,848
So that they inform their countries,

2050
02:47:53,056 --> 02:47:55,888
and say that in this country there is a real democracy.

2051
02:47:56,092 --> 02:47:59,323
Which doesn't exist in countries which talk about it so much.

2052
02:48:08,704 --> 02:48:10,331
I've been here for two days.

2053
02:48:12,208 --> 02:48:14,300
I've seen positive things.

2054
02:48:14,943 --> 02:48:17,377
And I've seen negative things.

2055
02:48:18,179 --> 02:48:19,669
Negative things such as:

2056
02:48:21,015 --> 02:48:25,975
There's no direct participation of workers here.

2057
02:48:26,287 --> 02:48:28,187
Grave error!

2058
02:48:28,656 --> 02:48:30,589
You must correct that.

2059
02:48:31,759 --> 02:48:34,091
The production committees...

2060
02:48:34,661 --> 02:48:37,994
have as essential base...

2061
02:48:38,298 --> 02:48:40,766
to let any comrade know,

2062
02:48:41,034 --> 02:48:44,094
wherever may he work,

2063
02:48:44,438 --> 02:48:46,599
what is the task...

2064
02:48:47,074 --> 02:48:54,140
he and all those who work at his section have to fulfil...

2065
02:48:55,081 --> 02:48:58,915
in the context of the plan that has to be discussed, analysed, criticised...

2066
02:48:59,218 --> 02:49:01,778
in partial meetings...

2067
02:49:02,054 --> 02:49:03,988
and then at the General Assemblies.

2068
02:49:04,323 --> 02:49:06,256
On Sunday...

2069
02:49:06,525 --> 02:49:08,925
or Saturday afternoons.

2070
02:49:09,261 --> 02:49:10,853
Do you understand?

2071
02:49:12,597 --> 02:49:14,656
It's very sad to hear that when...

2072
02:49:15,300 --> 02:49:19,361
assemblies are called to study the Plans...

2073
02:49:19,638 --> 02:49:23,004
not many comrades come.

2074
02:49:24,909 --> 02:49:28,242
That shows a lack of political conscience!

2075
02:49:29,380 --> 02:49:32,213
And where does all this process of change...

2076
02:49:32,716 --> 02:49:35,776
to see a different society rest on?

2077
02:49:36,053 --> 02:49:38,214
The workers!

2078
02:49:39,656 --> 02:49:43,319
On the production, the productivity!

2079
02:49:46,196 --> 02:49:48,687
The worker who takes part...

2080
02:49:48,965 --> 02:49:51,229
understands that before he was just another machine...

2081
02:49:51,534 --> 02:49:53,399
or even less than that.

2082
02:49:53,770 --> 02:49:55,499
Today, he's a human being...

2083
02:49:55,772 --> 02:49:58,763
who realises that this business belongs to him...

2084
02:49:59,041 --> 02:50:01,032
because it belongs to the people...

2085
02:50:01,310 --> 02:50:03,073
and he is part of the people.

2086
02:50:03,378 --> 02:50:05,778
And its awful to think...

2087
02:50:06,048 --> 02:50:07,675
that there are workers...

2088
02:50:07,950 --> 02:50:10,578
capable of stealing from their own industry,

2089
02:50:11,453 --> 02:50:13,944
from a factory that is his!

2090
02:50:15,556 --> 02:50:17,490
As I realised...

2091
02:50:19,760 --> 02:50:22,251
that there was a rejection...

2092
02:50:22,763 --> 02:50:25,288
of those who don't work well...

2093
02:50:25,566 --> 02:50:28,194
and are paid as though they did...

2094
02:50:28,469 --> 02:50:30,960
and it's very good that it was said!

2095
02:50:31,872 --> 02:50:35,330
The lazy cannot live at the expense of those who work...

2096
02:50:35,609 --> 02:50:39,409
nor can they be rewarded.

2097
02:50:39,679 --> 02:50:41,476
There can be no political tag...

2098
02:50:41,748 --> 02:50:44,808
for he who defends someone unwilling to work in a State enterprise.

2099
02:50:45,085 --> 02:50:47,076
The Party's card...

2100
02:50:47,354 --> 02:50:49,287
gives neither capacity nor honesty:

2101
02:50:49,555 --> 02:50:52,649
Each has to earn the right of being respected!

2102
02:51:04,837 --> 02:51:07,430
Would it be acceptable if you said:

2103
02:51:07,705 --> 02:51:10,640
"Levelling out, or otherwise, strike"?

2104
02:51:12,410 --> 02:51:14,378
Would it be fair? No!

2105
02:51:15,013 --> 02:51:17,106
Would it be effective? No!

2106
02:51:17,415 --> 02:51:19,076
Will I send in the police...

2107
02:51:19,517 --> 02:51:21,644
to send you back to work? No!

2108
02:51:21,920 --> 02:51:25,184
Will I promote confrontations that mean workers getting shot?

2109
02:51:25,522 --> 02:51:26,546
No!

2110
02:51:27,524 --> 02:51:30,982
I have to speak to you, I have to explain things to you...

2111
02:51:31,261 --> 02:51:33,161
to make you understand,

2112
02:51:33,797 --> 02:51:36,595
and if reason is not enough...

2113
02:51:36,867 --> 02:51:38,596
nor is moral strength,

2114
02:51:38,869 --> 02:51:41,336
I'll have nothing else to do but leave.

2115
02:51:41,604 --> 02:51:45,802
What am I going to do? Stay calm while I see that in this country,

2116
02:51:46,075 --> 02:51:48,703
unless drastic measures are taken,

2117
02:51:48,911 --> 02:51:52,813
we'll loose ourselves in an inflationist spiral?

2118
02:51:54,784 --> 02:51:56,411
No, I can't do that.

2119
02:51:57,353 --> 02:51:58,546
So,

2120
02:51:59,154 --> 02:52:03,687
we have all the disadvantages...

2121
02:52:04,092 --> 02:52:07,528
of the capitalist regime, without any advantage of socialism.

2122
02:52:07,729 --> 02:52:11,521
We are in the middle, comrades, sandwiched.

2123
02:52:12,500 --> 02:52:15,366
Yesterday I was saying:

2124
02:52:16,303 --> 02:52:18,567
What a drama it is for me...

2125
02:52:18,839 --> 02:52:21,467
that when I drive by with three cars,

2126
02:52:21,742 --> 02:52:23,972
because of security.

2127
02:52:24,244 --> 02:52:27,542
Because there are those who'd like I didn't have such a good health..

2128
02:52:36,923 --> 02:52:38,220
September 11, 1973

2129
02:52:39,233 --> 02:52:41,513
(Last image taken of Allende as President)

2130
02:52:41,693 --> 02:52:43,353
(Beatriz "Tati" Allende
Havana, September, 1973.)

2131
02:52:43,798 --> 02:52:47,595
I'm not here to read a speech. I come simply...

2132
02:52:47,867 --> 02:52:50,960
to say to this fraternal people...

2133
02:52:51,236 --> 02:52:54,899
how were the hours we lived at the Moneda Palace...

2134
02:52:55,207 --> 02:52:57,198
the morning of September 11.

2135
02:52:58,143 --> 02:53:00,737
In this act of solidarity with Chile,

2136
02:53:01,113 --> 02:53:02,705
I would like to tell you,

2137
02:53:02,981 --> 02:53:05,472
what my father asked me to transmit to you,

2138
02:53:05,751 --> 02:53:10,082
those words he confided me under fire:

2139
02:53:10,388 --> 02:53:14,552
"Tell Fidel I'll carry out my duty."

2140
02:53:28,670 --> 02:53:30,550
On October 13, 1977 Beatriz Allende
will commit suicide in Havana,

2141
02:53:36,950 --> 02:53:39,490
like her father had done four years earlier.

2142
02:53:41,484 --> 02:53:45,214
Today, from this free territory in America,

2143
02:53:45,521 --> 02:53:48,183
we can say to our comrade-president:

2144
02:53:48,457 --> 02:53:50,823
"Your people will not give in!

2145
02:53:51,126 --> 02:53:54,186
Your people will not fold the flag of Revolution

2146
02:53:54,463 --> 02:53:57,591
The struggle to the death with fascism has began...

2147
02:53:57,866 --> 02:54:00,993
and will end the day we have a free Chile,

2148
02:54:01,269 --> 02:54:03,430
sovereign, socialist...

2149
02:54:03,704 --> 02:54:07,003
for which you fought and gave your life.

2150
02:54:12,380 --> 02:54:14,746
Dear comrade-president,

2151
02:54:15,016 --> 02:54:16,778
We shall win!

2152
02:55:01,359 --> 02:55:04,692
Two people impressed me...

2153
02:55:04,996 --> 02:55:09,091
with something I couldn't find in others: Their gaze.

2154
02:55:10,033 --> 02:55:11,500
Chou-En-Lai...

2155
02:55:12,870 --> 02:55:14,428
and Che Guevara.

2156
02:55:15,072 --> 02:55:18,508
In both there was an inner strength.

2157
02:55:19,009 --> 02:55:22,103
In both there was resolve.

2158
02:55:22,379 --> 02:55:24,779
In both there was irony.

2159
02:55:31,224 --> 02:55:36,624
Imagine now that the person who did this film in 1977...

2160
02:55:36,625 --> 02:55:39,625
(Paris, May 1st, 1977)
had the opportunity to see this images after a long interval.

2161
02:55:40,625 --> 02:55:45,224
It could be, for example, 1993, 15 years later; What youth lasts.

2162
02:55:57,902 --> 02:56:02,741
He could meditate about how time passes and look at what has changed in a very simple way:

2163
02:56:03,061 --> 02:56:05,941
Listing words that had no meaning for the people of the '60s.

2164
02:56:06,701 --> 02:56:11,640
Words like: boat-people, AIDS: thatcherism,

2165
02:56:11,641 --> 02:56:17,461
ayatollah, occupied territories,
Perestroika, cohabitation.

2166
02:56:17,860 --> 02:56:20,700
And this acronym, that replaced USSR: that no-one would recognise:...

2167
02:56:20,701 --> 02:56:22,701
C.I.S.

2168
02:56:24,640 --> 02:56:25,760
The communist dream is over.

2169
02:56:27,160 --> 02:56:28,960
Capitalism won the battle, if not the war.

2170
02:56:30,680 --> 02:56:32,519
But in a paradoxical logic,

2171
02:56:32,520 --> 02:56:35,998
some of the staunchest opponents
of Soviet totalitarianism,

2172
02:56:35,999 --> 02:56:39,399
these men of the New Left to whom this film is largely devoted,

2173
02:56:39,839 --> 02:56:41,039
fell into the same whirlwind.

2174
02:56:42,299 --> 02:56:46,937
(Portugal, 1974)
The left opposition died with Stalinism. They were dialectically linked,

2175
02:56:47,197 --> 02:56:49,322
like the scorpion and the frog in Orson Welles' film.

2176
02:56:50,117 --> 02:56:52,374
It was their character.

2177
02:56:54,018 --> 02:56:57,297
For the fourth time, the terrestrial arms exposition...

2178
02:56:57,298 --> 02:56:59,217
has taken place in Satory...

2179
02:56:59,218 --> 02:57:02,097
to promote the exportation of...

2180
02:57:02,098 --> 02:57:04,938
the most modern arms available.

2181
02:57:05,438 --> 02:57:07,902
One hundred fifty expositors present seven hundred pieces of...

2182
02:57:08,264 --> 02:57:11,384
military equipment to forty foreign delegations.

2183
02:57:11,737 --> 02:57:14,456
Thus, our author marvels at the ingenuity...

2184
02:57:14,457 --> 02:57:17,997
of History, which always seems to have
more imagination than ourselves.

2185
02:57:18,120 --> 02:57:21,360
He thinks of the ending of the film he finished in 1977,

2186
02:57:22,057 --> 02:57:24,296
where he compared the arms trade of the great powers...

2187
02:57:24,297 --> 02:57:26,576
with the plans carried out...

2188
02:57:26,577 --> 02:57:29,336
to try to keep the population
of wolves at an acceptable figure.

2189
02:57:31,676 --> 02:57:34,056
Guess who they are arming today...

2190
02:57:44,900 --> 02:57:46,340
However, there's one comforting thought;...

2191
02:57:46,715 --> 02:57:49,875
Fifteen years later, there are still some wolves left.

2192
02:57:54,895 --> 02:57:58,934
The real authors of this film, though they haven't been consulted...

2193
02:57:58,935 --> 02:58:01,494
about the use given here to their documents,

2194
02:58:01,495 --> 02:58:04,613
are the countless cameras, sound engineers,

2195
02:58:04,614 --> 02:58:06,773
witnesses and militants whose work relentlessly...

2196
02:58:06,774 --> 02:58:09,773
opposes that of the Powers That Be,

2197
02:58:09,774 --> 02:58:12,094
and who will not leave our memory.


